Some quick points from me.
1) Col is my name, I post on here using it and its on all our KTM social media, so its not unusual for someone to use it. If they used Colin, I'd know who it was immediately, but my Mum doesn't use forums, so I think we're safe.
2) The warranty issue is really a moot point. Because in both cases being discussed here (actually all 3 if you count the bb issue thats been alluded to there is no issue. Second hand Haibikes don't have a warranty, so there is no reason why Martin should help anyone. If Martin isn't helping this customer Jresa, it could be for many reasons, but I'm sure the dongle isn't one of them.
Martin is clearly offering a warranty on the bikes he sells, so he has to honour them even if he puts a dongle on it - end of. The fact that bosch won't help him is not relevant to you guys who are end consumers. Unless he of course goes bust or closes and then you will be left high and dry unless Raleigh decide they too will go against Bosch and warranty bikes with a dongle.
3) My (our) and the industry concerns are that Martin is claiming to be promoting eBikes, when actually by selling bikes with dongles fitted he's not.
He's actually doing 2 things we have a problem with. Firstly by selling offroad bikes with dongles this is something that could cause the MTB side of eBikes to simply collapse in the UK, because we'll loose access rights everywhere. So this effects us, and lots of our customers who sell eMTBs and their customers who love riding their bikes at trail centres and parks everywhere.
Secondly, (and this doesn't have an impact on us really) he's selling bikes using an addition that most customers don't really understand the negative consequences of its use. This means he is benefiting from a non level playing field, this effects Haibike dealers more than ours but its a big problem. Because I know for a fact that if you phone his store you'll be told that Bosch bikes don't have enough speed normally, and the bikes are only really any good with a dongle. He pushes them on customers without really explaining the long list of reasons why they can cause you and the who community of cyclists problems.
So in short, yes I will be wandering over the Raleigh / Haibike to make a formal complaint at the NEC. I will then send an open letter to them, and having spoken to about 30 Haibike dealers over the past few weeks I don't think I'll be alone.
Col