Brexit, for once some facts.

derf

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 4, 2014
1,007
766
54
derf, that is unfair.

In post #6589 I said;



Again not condoning expenses fraud.

The point I am making is that fraud, if it exists within UKIP or any other party, is unacceptable and that it is unfair to claim that only UKIP MEPs are involved.
technically, yes, you are saying that fraud Is wrong (now that we have managed to make you do so). but, it all started with us presenting evidence of Farage's fraud, and your saying "everyone does it". that is dangerous. it's the same as overlooking his attempt to derail proper democratic protocol in trying to speak for the uk with trump. it's all about accountability, not having double standards, not being blind to what is really going on. brexit involved shedloads of that (lies, lack of accountability, saying "what's the worst that can happen", the public being hoodwinked).
 

D8ve

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 30, 2013
2,142
1,294
Bristol
Err OG Derf.
Tillson is the more reasoned one in the past few pages.
Could you try to up your anti and refrain from slurs, holocaust type comments.
Thanks
 

derf

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 4, 2014
1,007
766
54
Err OG Derf.
Tillson is the more reasoned one in the past few pages.
Could you try to up your anti and refrain from slurs, holocaust type comments.
Thanks
i disagree. I also, with respect, speak for myself, in the way that feels right for me. feel free to put a disagree or dislike next to my post. beyond that i'm afraid it's a matter of I wont tell you what to think or say and you wont tell me.
 

shemozzle999

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 28, 2009
2,826
686
Which means absolutely nothing and does not give him any authority to speak anywhere except at the EU parliament.
Why do you imagine it does? where did he get that added to his remit?
Lets have your answer to the following question.
Why does membership of any political party that is not in power allow you to make approaches to any Foreign head of state before there have been approaches by the Government in power?
Explain your logic.
What you are supporting is anarchy and little short of treason by the person making these personal advances.
Would you condone that in a time of war?
The Conservatives have a track record of doing this sort of thing remember.
The rule is that the Government in office represents us internationally on State matters, no individual is so empowered.
Dont like it? Get over it.
Mrs May made first contact with a phone call, Mr Trump received him, I don't believe there is a law preventing him to talk to him or any other party leader, where did I support anarchy or treason, there is no war between the USA and the UK and I very much doubt that the conversation was about State matters unless you where privy to them.
 

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
Err OG Derf.
Tillson is the more reasoned one in the past few pages.
Could you try to up your anti and refrain from slurs, holocaust type comments.
Thanks
Care to explain why?
And when did I mention the holocaust?
 

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
Mrs May made first contact with a phone call, Mr Trump received him, I don't believe there is a law preventing him to talk to him or any other party leader, where did I support anarchy or treason, there is no war between the USA and the UK and I very much doubt that the conversation was about State matters unless you where privy to them.
You missed the point yet again, and no doubt will refuse to do so whatever Farage does, it seems anything goes.
 

D8ve

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 30, 2013
2,142
1,294
Bristol
Care to explain why?
And when did I mention the holocaust?
Derf did post 6620.
Farage may be a right wing nut but like any pressure group he will be granted an audience, and as his politics are sufficiently close to trump having a meeting of like minded individuals is no surprise.
Trump knows that May represents the government/finance industries.

I may disagree with tillson but he is currently arguing with more class.
 

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
Mrs May made first contact with a phone call, Mr Trump received him, I don't believe there is a law preventing him to talk to him or any other party leader, where did I support anarchy or treason, there is no war between the USA and the UK and I very much doubt that the conversation was about State matters unless you where privy to them.
This is in fact what I wrote
"What you are supporting is anarchy and little short of treason by the person making these personal advances."
Two separate statements.
What you are supporting is anarchy
What else is it when someone jumps in to grab the limelight from the Government and self promote his agenda unofficially?
That is Anarchy, and you think it's OK
I pointed out that this could well occur when a tense situation exists and that anyone prepared to place himself before the Government is indeed exceeding his rights and trampling over ours to be properly represented, not by some self appointed "Hero" and that is little short of treason by the person making these personal advances.
Farage went to America to promote himself as usual
"http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/730276/Nigel-Farage-Donald-Trump-EU-job-ambassador
And what was the reaction from the UK Government?
"Crispin Blunt, chairman of the foreign affairs select committee, described as "completely implausible" the idea that Mr Farage would have an ambassadorial role in a Trump administration , telling the BBC there was "no need for Nigel".
Can you imagine the danger involved in these machinations?
 

derf

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 4, 2014
1,007
766
54
Derf did post 6620.
Farage may be a right wing nut but like any pressure group he will be granted an audience, and as his politics are sufficiently close to trump having a meeting of like minded individuals is no surprise.
Trump knows that May represents the government/finance industries.

I may disagree with tillson but he is currently arguing with more class.
well, that's your opinion. have a look at this
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-37965089
it's good, independent journalism.
you may note that I am not telling you what you can or cannot say. I would add that referring to obfuscation (about the only thing tillson seems to do) as good arguing isn't a very good sign, to put it politely.
 

D8ve

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 30, 2013
2,142
1,294
Bristol
well, that's your opinion. have a look at this
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-37965089
it's good, independent journalism.
you may note that I am not telling you what you can or cannot say. I would add that referring to obfuscation (about the only thing tillson seems to do) as good arguing isn't a very good sign, to put it politely.
Nor am I, just asking to avoid insults and wasteful exchanges.
I'm not on Tillsons side, I just want you to improve your arguments. :)
 

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
Derf did post 6620.
Farage may be a right wing nut but like any pressure group he will be granted an audience, and as his politics are sufficiently close to trump having a meeting of like minded individuals is no surprise.
Trump knows that May represents the government/finance industries.

I may disagree with tillson but he is currently arguing with more class.
It is the damage Farage can do that is my concern, he is very much a loose cannon, and so is Trump, it may be no surprise, it isn't to me, but the timing was calculated as a slight on May's premiership and nothing will convince me otherwise.
He is literally challenging her authority in the most blatant way.
"If you don't produce the Brexit I want, a word in someone's ear will make your plans impossible. is the implied threat"
I am astonished you don't see that.
Farage has set himself up with an improved power base
Tillson arguing with more class? smooth evasions,ignoring wrongdoing on Farage's part because others do it
tillson has a talent for that , but cannot conceal that his interest will discount wrongdoing by Farage as long as he is the champion of the Brexit cause.
The good old "The end justifies the means" rides again.
 

derf

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 4, 2014
1,007
766
54
Nor am I, just asking to avoid insults and wasteful exchanges.
I'm not on Tillsons side, I just want you to improve your arguments. :)
yet another point of view. for me classifying deliberate obfuscation as improving our arguments is a mistake. sometimes one has to call things what they are. rationalising Farage's corruption or trump's racism is not a step forward, in any possible sense.
 

tillson

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 29, 2008
5,252
3,197
Derf did post 6620.
Farage may be a right wing nut but like any pressure group he will be granted an audience, and as his politics are sufficiently close to trump having a meeting of like minded individuals is no surprise.
Trump knows that May represents the government/finance industries.

I may disagree with tillson but he is currently arguing with more class.
Would you like a cheque or direct cash bank transfer?
 
  • :D
Reactions: D8ve

tillson

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 29, 2008
5,252
3,197
technically, yes, you are saying that fraud Is wrong (now that we have managed to make you do so). but, it all started with us presenting evidence of Farage's fraud, and your saying "everyone does it". that is dangerous.
I have said from the outset that fraud is wrong and my position on that has never changed.
 

tillson

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 29, 2008
5,252
3,197
Which means absolutely nothing and does not give him any authority to speak anywhere except at the EU parliament.
Why do you imagine it does? where did he get that added to his remit?
Lets have your answer to the following question.
Why does membership of any political party that is not in power allow you to make approaches to any Foreign head of state before there have been approaches by the Government in power?
Explain your logic.
What you are supporting is anarchy and little short of treason by the person making these personal advances.
Would you condone that in a time of war?
The Conservatives have a track record of doing this sort of thing remember.
The rule is that the Government in office represents us internationally on State matters, no individual is so empowered.
Dont like it? Get over it.
I think that to liken Farage's informal meeting with Donald Trump to an act which is little short of treason or anarchy is over the top. At the very worst, he may be guilty of disrespect to Mrs May, but that is probably pushing it.

It's this sort of readiness to leap to extremes which causes me a degree of unease regarding your judgement. Are your forecasts for a post BREXIT Britain similarly exaggerated? Many, not all, of the more vocal remainers display similar characteristics.

I'm still optimistic about our future outside of the EU. I know that you will disagree with me and that it is unlikely that we will ever see eye to eye on the subject.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: mike killay

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
Wow! I love that one.....I don't understand it but it sounds good! It's a new one on me and there must be a description somewhere of how to do it but I haven't found it yet.o_O

Tom
Duke University ran a course on How to Reason and argue.
Apparently it is harder than it looks

"More than 220,000 students registered for the course; almost 128,000 watched the first video; approximately 78,380 attempted the first homework exercise and almost 10,000 students watched the final video. At the end, 5,322 students earned a Statement of Accomplishment with a substantial subset of 3,048 students earning a Statement of Accomplishment with Distinction.
This prompts some questions
  1. Was Farage among them?
  2. I wonder how many of the 3,048 were sufficiently adept to argue and get their money back?
  3. Have they had to register their mouths as Dangerous weapons?
  4. And how many of the ones who didn't make it managed to successfully deny they had ever heard of it and hide before being identified and "Conned" by the ones with the Distinctions?
Imagine that over 3000 dangerously argumentative individuals loose among the people of a nation accustomed to carrying Guns.
Who would deliberately offer a course as dangerous as that?

Just a bit of fun folks!
 

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
I think that to liken Farage's informal meeting with Donald Trump to an act which is little short of treason or anarchy is over the top. At the very worst, he may be guilty of disrespect to Mrs May, but that is probably pushing it.

It's this sort of readiness to leap to extremes which causes me a degree of unease regarding your judgement. Are you forecasts for a post BREXIT Britain similarly exaggerated? Many, not all, of the more vocal remainers display similar characteristics.

I'm still optimistic about our future outside of the EU. I know that you will disagree with me and that it is unlikely that we will ever see eye to eye on the subject.
Well, that's a start! disrespect is a very mild word for "Putting the screws on Mrs May" by forming alliances with a complete contempt for the Government of the country he is allegedly a citizen of.
Trying to affect the actions of the Government by influencing a Foreign head of State for personal advantage goes way beyond disrespect!
My forecasts for a post Brexit Britain?
Slow decline, increased National Debt, Unrest among the poor, dismantling bit by bit of the NHS (Unavoidable we will be told)
Drastic though slow lowering of living standards, Environmental Standards, and workers rights.
Widespread poverty, and the rich getting richer.
In fact a return to a the world I grew up in in the 1940's
And once the dust settles a long slow realisation that the EU wasn't the cause of the Brexit voters woes after all and that this was a very bad idea, and we will end up back in the EU within 10 years worse off and less influential than we are.
In the end a valuable lesson will be learned.
Unfortunately the whole population will be exposed to this unnecessary experiment and suffer because of the foolishness of 38% of the population.
That prediction is in fact an optimistic one, the signs are there for all to read.
By the way i rather like that line
"Are you forecasts for a post BREXIT Britain similarly exaggerated? Many, not all, of the more vocal leavers display similar characteristics."
It only needed one word to be changed.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: trex

Advertisers