Brexit, for once some facts.

flecc

Member
Oct 25, 2006
53,214
30,614
Barnier has said many times, the EU wants a deal but it must be one of the existing models. That is their position.
TM wants something that the EU considers a red line: effective SM and CU membership without accepting the ECJ, FOM and not paying into the kitty.
The EU can't give her that and she does not expect the EU will give in. She makes a lot of noises but the only possible reason is internal party management. She wants to push Gove into a corner: See? you have no better idea, have you? She knows that her position is so absurd that Raab has no hope to succeed, she therefore has to take on his job as negotiator in chief otherwise he'd just leave nearer to the deadline.
Yes I understand May's position, and that of the EU. But that doesn't make our getting CETA membership cut and dried, let alone CETA+. Canada has a say in that, even assuming the ECJ don't throw a spanner in the CETA works.

Whatever happens in the end, May will be a loser, historically a nonentity taking the blame for other's decisions to embark on an impossible course.
.
 
  • Like
Reactions: robdon

Woosh

Trade Member
May 19, 2012
20,386
16,882
Southend on Sea
wooshbikes.co.uk
if she does not get a deal, then the following may become plausible: she calls a second referendum, the hard brexiters will cry foul, confidence vote, she will win easily, everyone will sigh!! what a relief, we can vote again, this time, we are aware of the old lies.
No wonder that most recent bets (at the bookies) are on the second referendum.
 

anotherkiwi

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 26, 2015
7,845
5,786
The European Union
CETA is a foul piece of business - the first cheese to arrive from Canada with AOP sounding names will have the French farmers out burning lorries on the roadside again that is a certainty.

The whole "big business can sue government for loss of profit (estimated loss) in a private closed court" is an attack on justice. And the motives for such an attack on justice include environmental, consumer and worker protection.

"Free" and "trade" in the same sentence has always sent off alarm bells in my head - those shouting its virtues are usually the worst protectionists...
 

gray198

Esteemed Pedelecer
Apr 4, 2012
1,592
1,069
Do you earn your living doing stand-up in clubs? I honestly cannot believe that you are serious or that you expect to be taken seriously with that remark.

Tom
that's a bit rich coming from you. Someone who thinks that everyone who voted to leave is a fascist and a racist. I won't take of any notice of anything someone as bigoted as you says.
 

gray198

Esteemed Pedelecer
Apr 4, 2012
1,592
1,069
Gray 198....I assume by that comment you are still a committed Leaver,would you want a hard Brexit (no deal).
I don’t think Remainers are ‘pushing us in front of a bus’,that comment surely is more relevant to Brexiteers,especially the ERG group in parliament.
Leavers seem to fall back on meaningless sound bites....’taking back control’......we already have control of our money,we already have control of non EU immigration,we seem to be able to make our own laws,what more control do Leavers want?
Leavers don’t seem to be able to give any detail on what they are looking for and don’t seem to want to sensibly answer how our economy is going to improve after we Leave the EU.
Rees-Mogg admitted,surprisingly!,that the benefits of Brexit may take 50 years and his solution to the Irish border is let it sort itself out,he also said that lorries could go to Rotterdam instead of Calais,that would be bedlam.
The R-M,IDS,Bone,Redwood have a secret agenda that Brexit will advantage and they have been clever to hi-jack a big group to support that agenda,but I am sure that many of that group don’t really have any idea what the ERG have intended for them.
KudosDave
I do believe we should leave the EU. The people in this country never voted to join the EU. It has been forced on us by scheming politicians. I cannot see how it can be so hard to come to sensible trading arrangements with Europe without being a member of the club. They have what we want we have what they want. Why make it complicated. Truth is they want to be in total control and despite the mocking tone of some on here who have no faith in the UK, I think that we can be successful with the right leadership, and that would upset the cosy little protectionist cartel that the EU has become. Furthermore I want the people that we vote to power to be able to run the country for the benefit of it's citizens without interference from outside. If we don't have that, personally I do not see any point in voting for anyone. The downside is that we could end up with Corbyns crackpots in charge and that would be a far worse outcome than brexit. It is going to be difficult but it is necessary or we will just end up being governed from afar. I suspect that the few remainers on this thread will tear this view to pieces,but I also suspect that in the country at large there will be a lot of people thinking the same way.
 

oldtom

Esteemed Pedelecer
Someone who thinks that everyone who voted to leave is a fascist and a racist.
I have never said that every single person who voted leave is a racist nor have I said that every one of them is a fascist but this I can guarantee - every single racist and every single fascist voted leave! Claro?

You need to think about that.

Tom
 
  • Like
  • Dislike
Reactions: robdon and Zlatan

oldtom

Esteemed Pedelecer
After reading post #33606 from 'gray198', I actually believe that.....

37269406_1244136555721633_3833491863411621888_n.jpg

I don't know whether what he suffers is treatable but anyone clinging to such narrow-minded and anti-humanitarian views such as professed in post #33606 shouldn't be allowed out of the house unescorted, never mind being allowed to vote!:eek:

Tom
 
  • Like
Reactions: robdon

flecc

Member
Oct 25, 2006
53,214
30,614
I do believe we should leave the EU. The people in this country never voted to join the EU. It has been forced on us by scheming politicians. I cannot see how it can be so hard to come to sensible trading arrangements with Europe without being a member of the club. They have what we want we have what they want. Why make it complicated. Truth is they want to be in total control and despite the mocking tone of some on here who have no faith in the UK, I think that we can be successful with the right leadership, and that would upset the cosy little protectionist cartel that the EU has become. Furthermore I want the people that we vote to power to be able to run the country for the benefit of it's citizens without interference from outside. If we don't have that, personally I do not see any point in voting for anyone. The downside is that we could end up with Corbyns crackpots in charge and that would be a far worse outcome than brexit. It is going to be difficult but it is necessary or we will just end up being governed from afar. I suspect that the few remainers on this thread will tear this view to pieces,but I also suspect that in the country at large there will be a lot of people thinking the same way.
I won't tear your view to pieces, since I also recognise all the many faults of the EU which I'd rather be without.

Unfortunately I also recognise those of our governments which have been far worse for the individual than anything the EU did. I don't understand the dislike of the two European Courts when everything they've done for us has been such a great benefit for individuals, undoing or improving many of our governments more oppressive laws. I don't want to lose their valuable protection and revert to the evils of such as Michael Howard and Jack Straw when they were Home Secretaries.

I strongly object to being referred to as a subject with duties and responsibilities but no mention of rights. Instead I want to be known and respected as a citizen with rights, just like my fellow European citizens.

For all the above reasons I want to keep the invaluable Human Rights Act and not have it replaced by a Bill of (reduced) Rights of the sort the Tories want to keep us subjected to.

And since I lived though the long decline of the UK's manufacturing and commerce to almost non-existence before we joined the Common Market, I know how incompetent our governments have been at economics. It's a sad fact that the only time Britain was ever successful was with slavery and the captive market of an Empire held by force, obviously neither available or desirable any more.

Otherwise I've avoided mentioning the myths about Britain that so many who want to leave the EU believe, since the details usually cause offence and that is not my intention.

On balance for me, the undoubted faults of the EU are overwhelmed by the faults of us going it alone again, based entirely on the facts. No matter how attractive the ambitions of the Brexiters might be, they are only ambitions, unsupported by a shred of hard evidence.

Ergo, I prefer to remain in the EU, but must accept whatever agreement is reached, hopefully not too far from membership.
.
 

oyster

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 7, 2017
10,422
14,609
West West Wales
It will look perverse, but I agree with Tommie on this one. As I have said previously the island of Ireland has been united for millions of years, it is just that the people are not united. The fear (irrational in my opinion, but Tommie might differ) of an Ireland united under a government in Dublin is so srongly built into NI DUP DNA ,that they would oppose it. Bluntly we would not want to impose a united Ireland settlement on them, we want friendship.
From childhood, I could never understand why Ireland was split. Over the years I came to understand there are reasons but as the UK becomes less and less significant as a country, and as the republic looks to those outside less and less like a dependency of the Vatican, I had hoped that these reasons would reduce in importance. Eventually, perhaps, slowly becoming politically the same as it is geologically.
 

Kudoscycles

Official Trade Member
Apr 15, 2011
5,566
5,048
www.kudoscycles.com
I do believe we should leave the EU. The people in this country never voted to join the EU. It has been forced on us by scheming politicians. I cannot see how it can be so hard to come to sensible trading arrangements with Europe without being a member of the club. They have what we want we have what they want. Why make it complicated. Truth is they want to be in total control and despite the mocking tone of some on here who have no faith in the UK, I think that we can be successful with the right leadership, and that would upset the cosy little protectionist cartel that the EU has become. Furthermore I want the people that we vote to power to be able to run the country for the benefit of it's citizens without interference from outside. If we don't have that, personally I do not see any point in voting for anyone. The downside is that we could end up with Corbyns crackpots in charge and that would be a far worse outcome than brexit. It is going to be difficult but it is necessary or we will just end up being governed from afar. I suspect that the few remainers on this thread will tear this view to pieces,but I also suspect that in the country at large there will be a lot of people thinking the same way.
I read your posting but like most Leavers you don’t seem to have an alternative to the EU. Brexit has gone on long enough that the leave group should have detail as to what life after a hard Brexit will look like.
Rees-Moggs research group should be telling us how Leave intend to overcome the Irish border problem-to my knowledge they have no solution.
The ERG want us to turn our backs on 65 trade deals with the rest of the world,including Japan....we currently don’t appear to have any deals ready to sign.
Rees-Mogg has no solution to Calais-Dover trade interuption.
The EU have worked hard to unify standards throughout Europe,just look how out of date U.K. standards are....how often do you see a kite mark versus the EU logo? We have to make product to EU standards otherwise half the world will be excluded to our exporters.
This is all logical argument to stay,at least stay in the customs union.....why can’t Leavers come up with balanced logical reasons to Leave?
Liam Fox,said he would resign if May says we are staying in the customs union....that would be good for he would be redundant if we stay in a customs union,save May having to make him redundant.
It’s frustrating for Remainers that Leavers cannot see that they are being lead down a road by 50 Tory fascists who have no agenda other than to get their personal power back for selfish reasons....look up why Rees-Mogg likes Singapore so much,it has an economic model that benefits a wealthy few at the expense of virtual slavery for the poorer people....back to the same situation that existed in the 1930’s in England.
KudosDave
 

Kudoscycles

Official Trade Member
Apr 15, 2011
5,566
5,048
www.kudoscycles.com
I do believe we should leave the EU. The people in this country never voted to join the EU. It has been forced on us by scheming politicians. I cannot see how it can be so hard to come to sensible trading arrangements with Europe without being a member of the club. They have what we want we have what they want. Why make it complicated. Truth is they want to be in total control and despite the mocking tone of some on here who have no faith in the UK, I think that we can be successful with the right leadership, and that would upset the cosy little protectionist cartel that the EU has become. Furthermore I want the people that we vote to power to be able to run the country for the benefit of it's citizens without interference from outside. If we don't have that, personally I do not see any point in voting for anyone. The downside is that we could end up with Corbyns crackpots in charge and that would be a far worse outcome than brexit. It is going to be difficult but it is necessary or we will just end up being governed from afar. I suspect that the few remainers on this thread will tear this view to pieces,but I also suspect that in the country at large there will be a lot of people thinking the same way.
I don’t disagree that the EU are full of scheming politicians,but Brexit is ‘out of the frying pan and into the fire’....you surely must agree that Boris,Gove and Rees-Mogg are the most scheming politicians since Oliver Cromwell and Corbyn is not far behind.
If Boris decided to back Remain I would think the same.
Dominic Grieve,Soubry,Starmer and Umunna appear to be honest to their convictions whether they represent Remain or Leave.
KudosDave
 
  • Agree
Reactions: robdon and Woosh

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
I do believe we should leave the EU. The people in this country never voted to join the EU. It has been forced on us by scheming politicians. I cannot see how it can be so hard to come to sensible trading arrangements with Europe without being a member of the club. They have what we want we have what they want. Why make it complicated. Truth is they want to be in total control and despite the mocking tone of some on here who have no faith in the UK, I think that we can be successful with the right leadership, and that would upset the cosy little protectionist cartel that the EU has become. Furthermore I want the people that we vote to power to be able to run the country for the benefit of it's citizens without interference from outside. If we don't have that, personally I do not see any point in voting for anyone. The downside is that we could end up with Corbyns crackpots in charge and that would be a far worse outcome than brexit. It is going to be difficult but it is necessary or we will just end up being governed from afar. I suspect that the few remainers on this thread will tear this view to pieces,but I also suspect that in the country at large there will be a lot of people thinking the same way.
I do believe we should leave the EU. The people in this country never voted to join the EU. It has been forced on us by scheming politicians.

They did however vote on the earlier referendum as follows

Do you think that the United Kingdom should stay in the European Community (the Common Market)?
Note: European Community......
And those politicians were the official Government of this country duly elected to govern as they thought best


I cannot see how it can be so hard to come to sensible trading arrangements with Europe without being a member of the club. They have what we want we have what they want. Why make it complicated.
It isn't really, the EU has a set of membership rules that give additional privileges to members, we want those even though we won't be members, it's that simple, they will agree sensible trading agreements, but we want more
Truth is they want to be in total control
That isn't true, is it? We want full membership while not members, how hard is that to understand? It is WE who want to be in total control, and pay nothing.
and despite the mocking tone of some on here who have no faith in the UK, I think that we can be successful with the right leadership,
This is pure fantasy, the only successful companies here are under foreign ownership aren't they? where will these National saviours come from?

and that would upset the cosy little protectionist cartel that the EU has become.
We have benefited hugely from the "cosy little protectionist cartel that the EU has become.
It rescued us from bankrupcy and set us on the road to recovery from being the "Sick man of Europe" rescued by an IMF loan


4 Furthermore I want the people that we vote to power to be able to run the country for the benefit of it's citizens without interference from outside.

You are so wrong on this one it's hard to take you seriously!
How are you going to make the people you vote for change completely from the exploiters they are now t being virtuous?
They run the country for whoever buys their loyalty, and only want out to protect their offshore tax havens.
What interference from outside? care to give some examples? we have agreed with all EU laws because we were involved in making them.
Now thanks to the Brexit vote you have placed us in the position that you imagined we were in!


If we don't have that, personally I do not see any point in voting for anyone. The downside is that we could end up with Corbyns crackpots in charge and that would be a far worse outcome than brexit.
That is possibly true, but not guaranteed, to be honest I can't see anyone making Brexit work
It is going to be difficult but it is necessary or we will just end up being governed from afar.

We already are if you consider that the successful 50% of British businesses are foreign owned and run
How long before that becomes 75% or 80%?
Do you imagine the EU dictate laws we simply obey? We agreed and affected the formation of those laws and none were brought in without our agreement


Hasn't it penetrated that outside the EU you have placed us in the situation where to get the deal we want we either have to comply with the EU laws we no longer have any control over, or those of the WTO?
We will have to accept the jurisdiction of Foreign Courts with either choice.

I suspect that the few remainers on this thread will tear this view to pieces,but I also suspect that in the country at large there will be a lot of people thinking the same way.

All I can say it isn't necessary to tear your post to pieces.
It's already completely lacking cohesion, and based on inaccurate information.
And if there are still plenty of people thinking the same way, you do no doubt that is the one true thing you have stated.
The answer to that is that they simply refuse to think about the situation realistically
 
Last edited:

Danidl

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 29, 2016
8,611
12,256
73
Ireland
From childhood, I could never understand why Ireland was split. Over the years I came to understand there are reasons but as the UK becomes less and less significant as a country, and as the republic looks to those outside less and less like a dependency of the Vatican, I had hoped that these reasons would reduce in importance. Eventually, perhaps, slowly becoming politically the same as it is geologically.
Our histories are very different... Wales was conquered from around 1200, .. indeed that was why southern Ireland was invaded from Pembroke, , Scotland was finally conquered around 1700, with their act of union and Ireland was finally conquered in 1800 with our act of union. .. but things had changed by then and the rights of man and popular revolution was in the air. The Planation of ulster (1700-) was a form of ethnic cleansing, bringing in the right kind of person and expelling the indigenous. .. it had been tried before in other counties , but not as successfully. During the war of independence 1918/1922, the IRA also engaged in a policy of ethnic cleansing particularly in burning out the major farm owners and big house estates. These owners were not surprisingly the British or Anglo Irish . aristocratic class. Many went north or to the mainland and their workers with them. .. the IRA would have had no quarrell with any of the protestant workers, it would have been against the revolutionary ideals then current . But go they did, leaving the imbalance that continued. .. The time between the act of union and the fight for freedom is approximately the same as the time span from now back to the First World War, so you can see how live in memory would have been.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Reactions: robdon and flecc

Advertisers