Brexit, for once some facts.

PeterL

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 19, 2017
998
172
Dundee
I watched with pleasure the London section of the Sunday Politics program today with London MPs Karen Buck for Labour and Bob Neil for the Conservatives. Both confirmed they voted Remain and that in any second referendum they were emphatic that they would vote Remain again.

Additionally both were in perfect commonsense agreement on every subject discussed and constructively debating best approaches etc. It was a great example of the potential of co-operation in the common interest, in place of the Yah-Boo opposition for the sake of it that so infects our politics. Perhaps that's not surprising, by its nature the inclination to have voted Remain is a co-operative one.

Will we never have the wisdom to adopt proportional representation, which encourages much more of this sensible constructive behaviour?
.
I don't think the Brexit is really about lack of cooperation with our European neighbours and from my perspective far from it. I take your point about two people from different parties having a civilised conversation, refreshing. In the main the Tories seem more able to manage to remain civil whilst putting across different (sensible) policies and points of view than certainly the current front bench of the Labour Party. As for consensus politics, obviously, not our way is it, although not as bad as PMQ portray's. Most of the real work in HoC is done by the various committees and they are cross party and generally do a good job. Even then, most exchanges in the HoC and indeed on the AM Sunday show seem to indicate that there is hardly any real / substantial difference between the two major parties - for some reason one side wants to suggest that there are major differences.

I think this thread clearly shows just how difficult it would be have sensible and constructive behaviour on a regular basis?
 
Last edited:

PeterL

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 19, 2017
998
172
Dundee
Once General de Gaulle was out of the way, they always have been our friends. The problem has been that we've not fully accepted that friendship, just wanting to take the benefits while not contributing our share of the costs and not co-operating in the development of the union. That's not friendship, it's taking advantage and they are reasonably hurt by that attitude.
.
The General never got over being decanted to Swindon Railway Station during the war.
 

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
I don't think the Brexit is really about lack of cooperation with our European neighbours and from my perspective far from it. I take your point about two people from different parties having a civilised conversation, refreshing. In the main the Tories seem more able to manage to remain civil whilst putting across different (sensible) policies and points of view than certainly the current front bench of the Labour Party. As for consensus politics, obviously, not our way is it, although not as bad as PMQ portray's. Most of the real work in HoC is done by the various committees and they are cross party and generally do a good job. Even then, most exchanges in the HoC and indeed on the AM Sunday show seem to indicate that there is hardly any real / substantial difference between the two major parties - for some reason one side wants to suggest that there are major differences.

I think this thread clearly shows just how difficult it would be have sensible and constructive behaviour on a regular basis?
When you try to represent the conservatives in a favourable light you sound like Al Capones lawyer, and yet still make juvenile patronising comments.
Let's face it the self righteous Tory attitude is out of date and has got this country into a dreadful mess, and seems intent on making matters even worse.
Sensible policies and conservative , don't belong in the same sentence.
Only complete idiots would have used a referendum to try to quieten the idiot fringe of their party, and sure enough they didn't just do that but lost as well.
And now you call for sensible debate? The only sensible debate of how to cancel this farce, and get them out of office before they get to do any further damage to the nation.

Sent from my XT1032 using Tapatalk
 
  • Agree
Reactions: robdon and oldtom

Kudoscycles

Official Trade Member
Apr 15, 2011
5,566
5,048
www.kudoscycles.com
Rees-Mogg says that he wants the UK to be like Singapore.
So,I thought,I would look up Singapore-economically and socially...
Income Tax.....up to £10,000....tax free
up to £20,000....11%
above £160,000....22%
I have simplified it,there are extrapolated rates in between.
Pension and Healthcare
This is one payment(known as CPF) from the employer and reduces according to age.
Employee contribution....20% reducing to 5%
Employer contribution......17% reducing to 7%
Property Tax (Council Tax)....varies between 10-20% of the annual rent,rate varies according to the property type,
No capital gains tax and no inheritance tax.....our 'Toffs' would like that.
OK now the downsides...
No unemployment benefit
No housing benefit
No tax credits
No free healthcare system
No state pension system
Basically,no job you live off savings or get out.
There is a good employee redundancy system to act as a buffer if you lose your job and employment for skilled people is easy to get.
There is a dole but this is confined to those described as 'less fortunate' and is refused 50% of the time and offers benefit 41% below the lowest possible subsistence level.
There is almost no crime....burglary,spitting,throwing gum,graffiti,using drugs,rape can all be punished by caning...not a gentle caning,maximum sentence is 24 strokes of a rattan cane,even 6 strokes can be hospitalised and not able to sit or lie on back for a month.
Serious crimes and drug dealing....capital punishment is possible.
Is the unemployed guy in a poor part of the UK still sure about voting Brexit for Rees-Moggs form of society?????
KudosDave
 
  • Agree
Reactions: flecc

flecc

Member
Oct 25, 2006
53,208
30,608
As for consensus politics, obviously, not our way is it,

I think this thread clearly shows just how difficult it would be have sensible and constructive behaviour on a regular basis?
Many of the mainland Continental countries having proportional representation manage it ok, despite some very real political differences. The existence of the EU is proof enough.

We need to change our electoral system to benefit the same way, both in politics and among the wider public.
.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: robdon

Woosh

Trade Member
May 19, 2012
20,381
16,878
Southend on Sea
wooshbikes.co.uk
Is the unemployed guy in a poor part of the UK still sure about voting Brexit for Rees-Moggs form of society?????
he didn't know who JRM was until now.
Brexit has turned a few extremists like JRM into celebrities.
 

oldtom

Esteemed Pedelecer
Is the unemployed guy in a poor part of the UK still sure about voting Brexit for Rees-Moggs form of society?????KudosDave
Guys of the kind you mention are the kind who think we alone won the war, both world wars, in fact.

Their jingoism with its inherent racism is based on hand-me-down stories from their forebears who were, even a century ago, bombarded with propaganda delivered directly by the government through the BBC and also via the press of those days. Decade after decade, those people have succumbed to the government's message on behalf of the elite, a message also reinforced by their church leaders and their school teachers, encouraging the singing of patriotic songs and glorifying the sacrifice of millions of innocent young men for the most appalling reasons imaginable; sheer unadulterated greed, wealth expansion and the maintenance of the elite's control over ordinary people.

Lifelong brainwashing!

Those guys are no different today from the ones of the early part of the 20th century who rallied behind these lies and queued up to go and do their bit - they didn't have a clue!

22538910_1894042330912305_1298208533813435990_o.jpg

Very little has changed in the intervening years due to the relentless propaganda bombardment and a vote for Rees-Mogg will lead them to this:

22405428_1833640740009544_1942352381234887566_n.jpg

Tom
 

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
if we can't play fair, more reasons to leave, don't you think?
No. It is simply time we acted like responsible adults rather than the cast of Monty Python's Flying Circus.
Alas while people vote for the Conservatives this is all you can expect.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: robdon

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
Many of the mainland Continental countries having proportional representation manage it ok, despite some very real political differences. The existence of the EU is proof enough.

We need to change our electoral system to benefit the same way, both in politics and among the wider public.
.
It is notable that the Tory view is still that "their" view equates with "our" view in other words they OWN the proletariat.
Also notable is that the only form of debate "agreeable and rational" to a Tory, is acceptance of whatever they decide, no matter than the ideas inevitably fly as well as a lead Airship.
 

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
Rees-Mogg says that he wants the UK to be like Singapore.
So,I thought,I would look up Singapore-economically and socially...
Income Tax.....up to £10,000....tax free
up to £20,000....11%
above £160,000....22%
I have simplified it,there are extrapolated rates in between.
Pension and Healthcare
This is one payment(known as CPF) from the employer and reduces according to age.
Employee contribution....20% reducing to 5%
Employer contribution......17% reducing to 7%
Property Tax (Council Tax)....varies between 10-20% of the annual rent,rate varies according to the property type,
No capital gains tax and no inheritance tax.....our 'Toffs' would like that.
OK now the downsides...
No unemployment benefit
No housing benefit
No tax credits
No free healthcare system
No state pension system
Basically,no job you live off savings or get out.
There is a good employee redundancy system to act as a buffer if you lose your job and employment for skilled people is easy to get.
There is a dole but this is confined to those described as 'less fortunate' and is refused 50% of the time and offers benefit 41% below the lowest possible subsistence level.
There is almost no crime....burglary,spitting,throwing gum,graffiti,using drugs,rape can all be punished by caning...not a gentle caning,maximum sentence is 24 strokes of a rattan cane,even 6 strokes can be hospitalised and not able to sit or lie on back for a month.
Serious crimes and drug dealing....capital punishment is possible.
Is the unemployed guy in a poor part of the UK still sure about voting Brexit for Rees-Moggs form of society?????
KudosDave
Definitely, the papers can pull that off by making Jackass Mogg out to be a harmless comical figure but well meaning..
 
  • Agree
Reactions: oldtom and robdon

oldtom

Esteemed Pedelecer
Between 20% to 30% of population including us without electricity...and still a few hours to go...
That is not nice at at all 'Danidl' and I remember vividly the great storm of 1987 and the only slightly less damaging one of '88 because I had to be out and about on both occasions. Inevitably, severe weather in these isles seems to take a few unlucky souls and I believe today has been no exception and my thoughts go out to those bereaved and to those injured and/or made homeless.

From the news, it seems Ireland hasn't quite had a monopoly on this violent storm - I was at Woburn Abbey gardens and my straw hat almost blew off twice! Although it was shirt-sleeve order for me today, I had a rainproof in my rucksack but fortunately the rain didn't quite make it to a fairly warm Bedfordshire.

I hope you and yours have been able to remain safe.

Tom
 
  • Agree
Reactions: robdon

Advertisers