The new best headlight

  • Thread starter Deleted member 4366
  • Start date

anotherkiwi

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 26, 2015
7,845
5,786
The European Union
Can't use it on my roads. Mine is flat at the top and wider. One day I'll like my camera again and take it out.
 

cyclebuddy

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 2, 2016
1,640
771
Beds & Norfolk
The Magicshine Eagle F3. I'll take this any night of the week.
That light output is really impressive! So I checked out the Magicshine website, and see it has a 1/2kg battery pack that only lasts for 1.5 hrs at full tilt (those 4 x Cree XM-L2s really suck the juice it seems)!

And then I saw this, which they say is Magicshines most popular light, and uses just one Cree XM-L2. Looks very similar in style and spec to d8vehs... except this one costs £60!

Magicshine mj-858.jpg
http://www.magicshineuk.co.uk/bike-lights/front-bike-lights/mj-858-1000-lumens-2015-model.html

I recently bought one of the ones below, which has consistently been in Amazons top 5 "best selling" bike-light list for ages. Again like d8veh's, it's just a single Cree XM-L2 (which is why I chose it), but with a smaller, very compact, sealed solid plastic cased 2 x 18650 4400mAh tube-mount battery pack... which does last 3+hours at full brightness. The real issue is that it runs at cell voltage (4.2v@1.25A), so it's under-driving the Cree and giving less than the possible max 1200 Lumen output to start with, and fades further/a little as the cell voltage gradually drops. It does have a really nice solid/rigid clamp rather than a stretchy rubber band mount, and the best bit (for me) is that it uses a USB connector, so you can run it much brighter at 5.2v@1.8A (measured) off a separate/normal USB battery pack if you need even brighter light and/or longer runtime (and you recharge it off a standard USB too, so no dedicated 8.4v charger needed). In truth, because of the lower 3.7-5.2 running voltage it's not going to be as bright as d8vehs running at 8.4v, and so I doubt it'd be the best choice for full off-road/MTB use as some of you guys need, but it's still a great, more-than-bright-enough alternative for commuting/trail/on-road use. It's £25 at Amazon.

TeRichLED2.jpg
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Te-Rich-Rechargeable-HeadLights-Waterproof-Taillight/dp/B01HI48VKQ/
 

EddiePJ

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jul 7, 2013
4,632
4,013
Crowborough, East Sussex
www.facebook.com
That light output is really impressive! So I checked out the Magicshine website, and see it has a 1/2kg battery pack that only lasts for 1.5 hrs at full tilt (those 4 x Cree XM-L2s really suck the juice it seems)!
I must admit that I very rarely ever use the light at it's max. There are three modes, diffused beam, spot beam, and combined beam. I tend to use the diffused beam, set to maximum power setting. Using this combination, I only charge the light every other night ride, with each ride lasting 2.5hrs-3hrs as an average. Sometimes less, sometimes more.
 

gwing3

Finding my (electric) wheels
Oct 5, 2017
21
6
66
Chilterns, UK
I commend this one for your attention https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/10000Lumen-2x-XM-L2-LED-Bicycle-Bike-light-Cycling-Front-Head-Headlight-Headlamp/322587017989?hash=item4b1baf4305:m:mM6EUIoTMI8im8IGU7eh6Jw

However I recommend keeping your eye open for the same item offered without the charger and batteries and instead use it with a decent quality set of batteries in an 8.4V waterproof holder charged separately on a decent charger. Bought that way it costs peanuts (I paid £8 for mine) and much safer - I would personally never risk using any of the cheap charger/battery packs.

This light seems to have a much more usable beam pattern than most as one of the twin LEDs is the usual spot focus but the other has a fresnelly lens thing spreading the light into a very nice and wide horizontal bar so you get good near peripheral vision as well as distance. On the ebay page look at the 'low power' beamshot to see the shape, not the overexposed blobs on the high power pictures.

Colour rendition is reasonable, a bit nicer than some of the normally harsh blue-white cheap bike lights but nothing like a high CRI Zebralight in terms of either rendition or brigthness, nor price of course.

User interface is very simple, it would be nice if you could independently switch the two beams on and off but you can't, just a choice of brightness or flash.
 

KirstinS

Esteemed Pedelecer
Apr 5, 2011
3,224
899
Brighton
That light output is really impressive! So I checked out the Magicshine website, and see it has a 1/2kg battery pack that only lasts for 1.5 hrs at full tilt (those 4 x Cree XM-L2s really suck the juice it seems)!

And then I saw this, which they say is Magicshines most popular light, and uses just one Cree XM-L2. Looks very similar in style and spec to d8vehs... except this one costs £60!

View attachment 22252
http://www.magicshineuk.co.uk/bike-lights/front-bike-lights/mj-858-1000-lumens-2015-model.html

I recently bought one of the ones below, which has consistently been in Amazons top 5 "best selling" bike-light list for ages. Again like d8veh's, it's just a single Cree XM-L2 (which is why I chose it), but with a smaller, very compact, sealed solid plastic cased 2 x 18650 4400mAh tube-mount battery pack... which does last 3+hours at full brightness. The real issue is that it runs at cell voltage (4.2v@1.25A), so it's under-driving the Cree and giving less than the possible max 1200 Lumen output to start with, and fades further/a little as the cell voltage gradually drops. It does have a really nice solid/rigid clamp rather than a stretchy rubber band mount, and the best bit (for me) is that it uses a USB connector, so you can run it much brighter at 5.2v@1.8A (measured) off a separate/normal USB battery pack if you need even brighter light and/or longer runtime (and you recharge it off a standard USB too, so no dedicated 8.4v charger needed). In truth, because of the lower 3.7-5.2 running voltage it's not going to be as bright as d8vehs running at 8.4v, and so I doubt it'd be the best choice for full off-road/MTB use as some of you guys need, but it's still a great, more-than-bright-enough alternative for commuting/trail/on-road use. It's £25 at Amazon.

View attachment 22253
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Te-Rich-Rechargeable-HeadLights-Waterproof-Taillight/dp/B01HI48VKQ/
Ahhh, this explains, I think, why my two cree solar storm out performs my 3 cree version

The two cree runs off USB packs, the 3 cree one off 8.4v of 18650
 

cyclebuddy

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 2, 2016
1,640
771
Beds & Norfolk
I commend this one for your attention... 10000Lumen 2x XM-L2-LED... it costs peanuts (I paid £8 for mine)
This may well be a very good bike light, and I wouldn't argue with that if it suits your purpose.

But it always confuses me how any seller can claim any XM-L light can produce 10,000 Lumens when the latest XM-L2 is (from Cree's own website) the "highest performing commercially available single-die LED"... and the XM-L2 produces a maximum of 1198 Lumens? (I think the original XM-L was about 1000 Lumens IIRC).

And how can they do the complete light with 2 x XM-L2 for £8 when the bare, genuine XM-L2 LEDs just on their own cost between £2.50 and £4 each? (The cost difference is between the colour temperature - warm/cool light).

There is some info out there which explains how to tell an L2 from the original L... and how to spot a fake.
 

soundwave

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 23, 2015
17,001
6,536
DSC_0660.JPG
;)
 

gwing3

Finding my (electric) wheels
Oct 5, 2017
21
6
66
Chilterns, UK
This may well be a very good bike light, and I wouldn't argue with that if it suits your purpose.

But it always confuses me how any seller can claim any XM-L light can produce 10,000 Lumens when the latest XM-L2 is (from Cree's own website) the "highest performing commercially available single-die LED"... and the XM-L2 produces a maximum of 1198 Lumens? (I think the original XM-L was about 1000 Lumens IIRC).

And how can they do the complete light with 2 x XM-L2 for £8 when the bare, genuine XM-L2 LEDs just on their own cost between £2.50 and £4 each? (The cost difference is between the colour temperature - warm/cool light).

There is some info out there which explains how to tell an L2 from the original L... and how to spot a fake.
Oh, that's easy to answer - China uses a special type of lumen that does higher numbers. Obviously none of these cheapy lights produce anywhere near the claimed output.

The output from this one is *nowhere near* the output from a selectively binned Cree in a properly engineered torch driven hard by a top class driver - but neither are any bike lights I've seen. That said it is a reasonable bit brighter than my sample of the lamp originally recommended in this thread. You do have to be realistic in what you expect from an £8 light and I'm very aware its lifetime could be anywhere from 15 minutes to a few years.
 

soundwave

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 23, 2015
17,001
6,536
Oh, that's easy to answer - China uses a special type of lumen that does higher numbers. Obviously none of these cheapy lights produce anywhere near the claimed output.

The output from this one is *nowhere near* the output from a selectively binned Cree in a properly engineered torch driven hard by a top class driver - but neither are any bike lights I've seen. That said it is a reasonable bit brighter than my sample of the lamp originally recommended in this thread. You do have to be realistic in what you expect from an £8 light and I'm very aware its lifetime could be anywhere from 15 minutes to a few years.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: LeighPing

cyclebuddy

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 2, 2016
1,640
771
Beds & Norfolk
...Obviously none of these cheapy lights produce anywhere near the claimed output.
Obvious to who exactly? Clearly a lot of folk on this and other cycle forums (you included) are fairly clued up, but I'd argue not the majority who frequent Ebay.

If I buy a product clearly advertised as McVities Jaffa Cakes I expect exactly that... not some poor, crass, half-baked imitation without *any* orange goo in them... even if they do taste half reasonable and appear ridiculously cheap!
 

gwing3

Finding my (electric) wheels
Oct 5, 2017
21
6
66
Chilterns, UK
Obvious to who exactly? Clearly a lot of folk on this and other cycle forums (you included) are fairly clued up, but I'd argue not the majority who frequent Ebay.

If I buy a product clearly advertised as McVities Jaffa Cakes I expect exactly that... not some poor, crass, half-baked imitation without *any* orange goo in them... even if they do taste half reasonable and appear ridiculously cheap!
Yes, but. If those jaffa cakes were advertised on ebay by an unknown seller in China offering to sell them at 5p per dozen packs delivered free to your door with real organic goo lovingly produced by some non politically correct maiden you might suspect they weren't really McVities cakes and might not taste the same even if it was worth investing 5p out of interest.

However I take your point, many people know a lot less about Lithium battery packs and their dangers than Jaffa cakes so it isn't at all obvious to them and I regret the phrasing.
 
  • :D
Reactions: Gringo
D

Deleted member 4366

Guest
The number of lumens isn't important. having tried a large number of lights with different Cree emitters, in can tell you that the light mentioned in the OP is amongst the brightest of the single emitter ones. It gives more than enough light for the average cyclist. It's cheap, it looks cool, it's durable, the battery lasts long enough for long journeys, it's unobtrusive and it's light weight. Even when I ride on unlit cycle tracks, I rarely set it on maximum. I keep looking at other lights, but I haven't yet seen anything that I would consider better. You can a bigger and heavier one, a brighter but not long lasting one, etc., but i haven't yet seen another one with all the desirable characteristics at once.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oldtom and VictoryV

Kenny

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jun 13, 2007
383
111
West of Scotland
Could someone please tell me what what type of connector this light has.

I have an excellent waterproof Tecknet 10000mAh power pack I occasionally use for charging my phone.
It has a USB power out and I was wondering if I could use this to power this light rather than buying another power pack.
 

soundwave

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 23, 2015
17,001
6,536

Kenny

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jun 13, 2007
383
111
West of Scotland
Thanks very much for the informative reply's Dave and soundwave.

I've used the excellent (but very expensive) Exposure Strada for many years which I swap between my bikes.

This one looks great value so I think I'll give it a try.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: LeighPing

Gaz

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 14, 2016
720
556
54
Eastbourne
....and I'm very aware its lifetime could be anywhere from 15 minutes to a few years.
Mine lasted all of about two minutes. Either my fault for not waterproofing the battery before I used it, or some twerp in China's fault for not realising they'll go pop as soon as they encounter a decent bit of rain.

Gaz