I'm quite fascinated by the potentials of AI as you probably noticed and have been exploring the potential for AI to simulate or acquire conscious experience.As Andybike suggested, I modified the query slightly to add a qualifier here in bold and gave it to ChatGPT. Here is the new query:
Can a person who came from Afghanistan and arrives in a rubber boat from France which is a safe and civilised country, honestly apply for asylum in the UK?
And here is the reply:
Reasoned about asylum application eligibility for 16 seconds
Yes, they can apply for asylum regardless of how they arrived. In the UK, the right to seek asylum is based on an individual’s claim of persecution or danger in their home country—not on the route taken to get there.
Key Points
In summary, yes—a person fleeing Afghanistan can honestly apply for asylum in the UK even if they entered from France via a non-standard route. The ultimate success of the claim will depend on the specifics of their case and their ability to demonstrate a genuine need for protection.
- Right to Apply:
Even if someone enters by an irregular route (such as by rubber boat), they have the legal right to apply for asylum if they can demonstrate a well-founded fear of persecution or harm in Afghanistan.- Scrutiny of Entry Route:
The manner of entry may be considered by immigration authorities. Irregular entry can complicate the process and might affect how the claim is handled, but it does not automatically disqualify the applicant.- Safe Third Country Consideration:
While France is considered a safe and orderly country, the fact that the journey started there does not necessarily preclude an asylum claim in the UK. However, if authorities determine that the applicant could have sought protection in France (a “safe third country”), this might be examined during the processing of the claim.- Legal Advice Recommended:
Given the complexities of asylum law and the potential implications of an irregular entry, it’s crucial for anyone in this situation to seek advice from a qualified immigration lawyer or a trusted refugee support organization.

the link seems to dump you at the end of the discussion so scroll to the top to see the start.