Ongoing reliability of Kalkhoff/Focus Impulse 2 motors

Croxden

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 26, 2013
2,134
1,384
North Staffs
I see more BMW's on the hard shoulder than any other of the newish cars.
 

flecc

Member
Oct 25, 2006
53,136
30,556
What's more unreliable, a merc, a beamer or a kalkhoff?
The Kallkhoff Agattu and Pro Connect bicycles were and still are very good bikes, good design and build quality. And when they decided to make electric versions back in 2007, they used the excellent series 2 Panasonic 26 volt crank unit.

The outcome were two of the best e-bikes ever to hit the market, some members commuting on them ever since. Even better, their batteries lasted five years too.

But then they decided they wanted to use a German crank unit and adopted the Daum one, calling it Impulse in a pretence it was their own. That was the first of the German crank drive designs and had sold very few independently. The first series wasn't bad, the failure rate very low, but with more powerful competitors such as Bosch arriving, they upped the Impulse power for the series 2, and the rest is history.

If only they'd stuck with Panasonic they'd have got their 36 volt later unit and avoided all the troubles.
.
 

anotherkiwi

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 26, 2015
7,845
5,786
The European Union
I've seen mercs and BMWs very low down on reliability surveys. Audi/VW tend to be a lot better. I think German engineering quality is a mythology.
No, it has just gone downhill like everywhere else as companies try to increase profit margins. German engineers are highly qualified but they lack imagination so they conceive products that are more and more bland IMO. With ZF getting into the electric bike business with various partners there might be a shakeup ahead.

The whole Kalkhoff farce is because they brought motor manufacturing in house to increase profit margins. They are pretty good at building bikes but not very good at building motors.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: oriteroom and flecc
D

Deleted member 4366

Guest
I've seen mercs and BMWs very low down on reliability surveys. Audi/VW tend to be a lot better. I think German engineering quality is a mythology.
Back in the 70s. the German car makers were probably the only ones to use proper quality controls. They were based on following rigid routines to adhere to standards. The result was what we call "solid German engineering", where the product would be very robust at the expense of other parameters.

During the 70s, the Japanese started using a more cooperative approach based on statistics, so they leapt ahead of everyone on quality. It wasn't until the late 80s that the British and American car producers recognised the gap, so they paid the Japs to show them how to do it, while the Germans, on the whole, kept to their rigid routines.

During the 90s, everybody tried hard using every technique available, but there were three fundamental approaches. the Germans focused on rigid routines and standards, the Japs kept their cooperative approach and the British added creativity into their systems. at that point, I'd say that the big German producers, in particular Mercedes-Benz, were slipping behind. I packed it all in in 2000, so I've lost touch of where they all stand now.

I've seen fundamental flaws in the way German companies approach quality - mainly that the hierarchical structures lead to arrogance rather than cooperation, but, generally, they still do a good job.

Reputations always are based on results from a long time ago.
 
  • Like
Reactions: grldtnr

topographer

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 13, 2017
559
216
Mid Yorkshire
Reputations always are based on results from a long time ago
True indeed. Apparently, in the Victorian period, German engineering products were considered poorly made tat by British standards but the Germans made a concerted effort to up their game and soon matched or overtook us. (I think I heard this on a BBC4 documentary).
 

philliptjohnson

Pedelecer
Jun 12, 2017
48
29
50
Washington
Sony apparently started out as a company with a reputation for producing cheap low quality tat, their main product being a deep fat fryer if memory serves correctly. They made it their mission one day to turn that opinion around and be known for high quality.
 

Danidl

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 29, 2016
8,611
12,256
73
Ireland
Not quite, Sony were the first company to licence transistor manufacture, the second company to put a transistor radio set on the market, and the first to do so with their own transistors. My family had one in Ireland in 1957.! ( Yes that date is correct) . I was given access to it and continued to " improve " it until it stopped working... Making me very popular with my parents...
 

Crockers

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 19, 2014
821
689
71
German engineering also gained by losing the war. New machinery.

Saab suffered from over engineering their cars. They went on forever. Forgetting that people need to buy new ones on a regular basis to make a profit.
then GM bailed them out and the rest is history. Beware of Americans bearing gifts.
 

flecc

Member
Oct 25, 2006
53,136
30,556
Saab suffered from over engineering their cars. They went on forever. Forgetting that people need to buy new ones on a regular basis to make a profit.
then GM bailed them out and the rest is history. Beware of Americans bearing gifts.
SAAB never sold enough, regardless of who was in charge. Making 4000 or less per model per annum was never going to be viable long term.
.
 

Croxden

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 26, 2013
2,134
1,384
North Staffs

Rob-KTM

Finding my (electric) wheels
Oct 3, 2016
11
3
42
Torbay,Devon
Hi,

Has anyone had any luck getting a refund?

I ask as we have two impulse 2 powered Kalkhoff bikes, both of which are now failing again.. This will be their second motor replacement in less than 18 months!! The bikes where bought from 50cycles.

We live in Devon so miles from 50cycles to keep taking the bikes back!! also the main issue is breaking down as it is rather hilly around here so would be completely stuck!

Rob
 

Peter Thornton

Pedelecer
Apr 15, 2017
104
67
73
Kendal
Hi,

Has anyone had any luck getting a refund?

I ask as we have two impulse 2 powered Kalkhoff bikes, both of which are now failing again.. This will be their second motor replacement in less than 18 months!! The bikes where bought from 50cycles.

We live in Devon so miles from 50cycles to keep taking the bikes back!! also the main issue is breaking down as it is rather hilly around here so would be completely stuck!

Rob
Try and negotiate a swap to the Kalkhoff Bosch powered bikes. It would be worth you offering to put some money towards it, if a deal can be done.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rob-KTM

Peter Thornton

Pedelecer
Apr 15, 2017
104
67
73
Kendal
I have a Pro Connect B10 (The B signifying Bosch) which I've only had for a few weeks and just approaching 400 miles on the clock. I do like it and the cycle parts all seem of good quality. I've only ever heard people complain about the Impulse motor the rest of the bikes seem fine.
 

Steb

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jul 15, 2017
328
613
46
london
Is there really such thing as a 2.2 version?

Apart from the 50 Cycles site, I can't really find any reference to the Impulse 2.2 motor, even on the Kalkhoff site. On the 50 Cycles site, when you look at the full specification pictures for the various bikes (example: Pro Connect i10), the Kalkhoff documents say "Impulse 2.0".

Their own Beat range was supposed to be on 2.2, but some people have reported here receiving 2.0 motors.
apologies for bumping a long post - but I'm contemplating a kalkhoff beat - does anyone know if the impulse 2.2 is reliable? I gather the impulse 2.0 had problems. does anyone have longer term experience of a kalkhoff beat with impulse 2.2? I wonder what the top speed is, and whether the lack of a suspension fork is an issue given our third world pot holed roads?