My name is ..... And I'm new here.....

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,531
3,277
One unascendable hill is one too many... I'd sell it, buy a bike/trike easier to convert with a mid-drive kit.
 
Last edited:

FastFreddy2

Pedelecer
Apr 19, 2023
186
87
One unascendable hill is one too many... I'd sell it, buy a bike/trike easier to convert with a mid-drive kit.
That would be putting the cart before the horse. If you have read the whole thread, you will know the owner is not young. A bicycle hasn't been ridden by the owner for some considerable time, more than 50 years. A minor incident with them coming off a bicycle, could be a death sentence, as a broken hip often can be with those in their later years.

Why a Kettwiesel Evo? Tadpole types sit lower. The owner could not get into and out of the seat in a suspension ICE e-trike without assistance because the seat is so low to the ground. The seat on the Lepus sits higher, which is good, but the seat is pushed against the underneath of the thighs, when the reach is adjusted for shorter legs. The Trigo is a better fit, but the seat is narrower so again uncomfortable.

The most comfortable, most suitable for size of rider frame, most accessible, was the Kettwiesel. Believe me, no small amount of effort/research went into the purchase.

So the 'cart' part of the combination does not involve a choice of any sort. The only choice comes with 'what horse'.

This has be solved at least once before, but I'm not sure the owner still visits? No posts here for 6 years. Post #4 on this thread.

 
Last edited:

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,531
3,277
That would be putting the cart before the horse. If you have read the whole thread, you will know the owner is not young. A bicycle hasn't been ridden by the owner for some considerable time, more than 50 years. A minor incident with them coming off a bicycle, could be a death sentence, as a broken hip often can be with those in their later years.
Falling over attempting to push a heavy trike uphill would also cause problems. Of course broken or fractured bones don't heal well for persons of advanced age, which is why I said:

One unascendable hill is one too many... I'd sell it, buy a bike/trike easier to convert with a mid-drive kit.
I really don't see a legal 250W hub drive being approriate, others with hub drive motors may disagree (but they'd be wrong IMHO, because the rider is not young).


This has be solved at least once before, but I'm not sure the owner still visits? No posts here for 6 years. Post #4 on this thread.
In that instance using a 350W motor. If staying legal isn't important and you want to try a hub motor for this project - if compatible, @Benjahmin 's Dillinger kit really has to go:

The Dillinger kit really has to go.
 
Last edited:

matthewslack

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 26, 2021
1,967
1,416
ICE have a couple of specialist tadpoles which would give better stability and easily take a mid drive. The Adventure and Adventure HD for normal use, and the Full Fat for going anywhere. Including electric versions. But budget can quickly get out of hand.

 
  • Like
Reactions: guerney

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,531
3,277
ICE have a couple of specialist tadpoles which would give better stability and easily take a mid drive. The Adventure and Adventure HD for normal use, and the Full Fat for going anywhere. Including electric versions. But budget can quickly get out of hand.

Someday, one of those will be mine! But only when there are lightweight fully enclosed versions available, with solar panel arrays on the roof.
 
  • Like
Reactions: matthewslack

FastFreddy2

Pedelecer
Apr 19, 2023
186
87
Falling over attempting to push a heavy trike uphill would also cause problems.
Not with the owner. There will be very little pushing of trikes anywhere, and there will certainly be no pushing of anything uphill.

I really don't see a legal 250W hub drive being appropriate, others with hub drive motors may disagree (but they'd be wrong IMHO, because the rider is not young).
This is where experience should make a difference to the purchasing decision.

There is the query over whether even a 250w motor would have too much torque and not enough weight to prevent the wheel spinning. Speed is not going to be an issue with the owner, who will be thinking 8mph will be plenty fast enough.

In that instance using a 350W motor. If staying legal isn't important and you want to try a hub motor for this project -
Ideally, a fully legal system would be preferred. However, if there isn't enough torque in a 250w motor to pull the trike and rider up slopes, then there might be a need to get a 350w hub motor instead.

The Dillenger kit looked interesting, but only 250w hub available for a 20" wheel, which may be sufficient anyway? Thanks for the nod in that direction.
 
  • Like
Reactions: guerney

FastFreddy2

Pedelecer
Apr 19, 2023
186
87
ICE have a couple of specialist tadpoles which would give better stability and easily take a mid drive. The Adventure and Adventure HD for normal use, and the Full Fat for going anywhere. Including electric versions. But budget can quickly get out of hand.
As above/before, the ICE trikes are simply too low.
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,531
3,277
The Dillenger kit looked interesting, but only 250w hub available for a 20" wheel, which may be sufficient anyway? Thanks for the nod in that direction.
I've avoided hubs thus far, because I have my doubts about whether a legal 250W hub motor would do everything that my mid-drive does (BBS01B) - it has both torque for hills and speed on the flat. Some people who rave on these forums about hub motors vs 250W mid-drives, use 350W or 500W(and +) motors. And I'm now braced for a diatribe... :rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zlatan

flecc

Member
Oct 25, 2006
53,260
30,648
This has be solved at least once before, but I'm not sure the owner still visits? No posts here for 6 years. Post #4 on this thread.

But he hadn't solved it Freddie. He was in flat Norfolk and commented on that. There is no way the motor he chose would cope with a 20% or 25% hill.

You've already correctly identified the opposing problems, being stuck with one trike model which inherently cannot give enough front wheel tyre adhesion for a motor powerful enough to get up hills of 20 to 25% without much rider help.

Somehow the front would need a lot more weight to have sufficient grip for an illegal power motor/controller combination, probably about 750 watt rating.
.
 

soundwave

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 23, 2015
16,998
6,536
a motor can be 1000w but it must not go faster than 15mph as that's what the law says as no 250w motor is getting you up any hill.

i have seen a Yamaha bike with a watt meter in between the batt and the motor and with a dongle it went as high as 800w.

so 800w under 15mph is fine but over that speed it is not which then just confuses the crap out of ppl just get pissed and ride it anyway :p
 

soundwave

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 23, 2015
16,998
6,536

FastFreddy2

Pedelecer
Apr 19, 2023
186
87
I'm pretty sure this is the animal a friend of the family owns. The owner loves it, but has ridden a bicycle all her life. She now lives on one of the islands in the Inner Hebrides, so perfectly suitable transport there. Shame it isn't a recumbent.
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,531
3,277
Last edited:

matthewslack

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 26, 2021
1,967
1,416
Ok, I hadn't realised quite how high the Kettwiesel seat is. 48 to 50cm from a quick look, with ICE Full Fat only 42cm.

I think we've reached 'you can't have everything' territory!

You can have a front hub on the Kettwiesel, and the high seat, but you likely won't get up the hill. You can choose the highest tadpole seat design, add a mid motor, and get up the hill. Or find a competent engineer to rework the Kettwiesel steering around a mid motor...

Can you work around that hill?
 
  • Like
Reactions: FastFreddy2

FastFreddy2

Pedelecer
Apr 19, 2023
186
87
But he hadn't solved it Freddie. He was in flat Norfolk and commented on that. There is no way the motor he chose would cope with a 20% or 25% hill.

You've already correctly identified the opposing problems, being stuck with one trike model which inherently cannot give enough front wheel tyre adhesion for a motor powerful enough to get up hills of 20 to 25% without much rider help.

Somehow the front would need a lot more weight to have sufficient grip for an illegal power motor/controller combination, probably about 750 watt rating.
This isn't the sort of remark that is suggesting the quest is making progress. ;)

The configuration worked for the rider, who themselves said the motor helped their fairly able riding ability. But I don't remember them writing they only rode in Norfolk? Either way, a motor that can use more power is not off the cards, it's where the purchasing choice gets pitched, meaning 350w, 500w ..... 36v or more?

The Wiesmann 250w motor is sold in a place where the land in the UK is not flat. No reviews that suggest it isn't up to the job? I am becoming resigned to having to acquire a 250w motor under a 'suck it and see' initiative, with the prospect of a 350w replacement. I'm not even sure higher consumption 20" wheels are readily available. Maybe I should look? What I don't really want to waste money on, is the battery pack. That really should be a one-off purchase.
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,531
3,277

UltimateEbike Ltd

Unit A, 82 James Carter Road, Mildenhall, Suffolk, IP28 7DE, United Kingdom

Telephone: 03333582770
Mobile: 07391152448
WhatsApp: +447391152448
Email: Enquiries@ultimateebike.com

 

soundwave

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 23, 2015
16,998
6,536
if you want a bomb proof motor and all parts can be bought for it get one of these and the programme cable then you can set the power limits to what they like.


m8 has one of those on a bike frame that is 20 years old and uses it for work every day in all weathers and not stopped once.
 

FastFreddy2

Pedelecer
Apr 19, 2023
186
87
Ok, I hadn't realised quite how high the Kettwiesel seat is. 48 to 50cm from a quick look, with ICE Full Fat only 42cm.

I think we've reached 'you can't have everything' territory!

You can have a front hub on the Kettwiesel, and the high seat, but you likely won't get up the hill. You can choose the highest tadpole seat design, add a mid motor, and get up the hill. Or find a competent engineer to rework the Kettwiesel steering around a mid motor...

Can you work around that hill?
I very much like your summary of the situation. I had sent a link to the owner yesterday, and I'm sure they are watching the progress of the prospective project. (You can be sure, the whole enterprise will be well documented here.)

Originally, I had hoped that vendors might work with us to produce a working solution. What do I mean buy that? Retail outlets who maybe carried stock of a number of hub wheels, would use "our" Kettwiesel as a testing ground for a solution they might offer the Hase owners in the UK. I know for fact (because I've met a few) they are often elderly folk who have enjoyed riding a bike then trike, but had to give up riding because they become too infirm for pedalling up hills. My partner who used to cycle some 5 miles each way to work every work day, will not get on a bike now, for that very reason..... I truly believe, e-bikes, e-trikes bring back the joy we all used to have when we were young and fit, and would ride our bikes out somewhere just for the pleasure of the journey.

The Kettwiesel ought to be a trike that can be easily converted to an e-bike, but the basic design has ensured this is very difficult. Hase has recently altered their range of recimbents to reflect the market demand for e-trikes, though others in their range are easier to convert.

In another life, I was a welder. I am thinking that possibly, a simple route that could solve all the barriers, is to have the Kettwiesel boom cut, and welded back together, but with the bottom bracket rotated 180' from its present position. This would allow a mid-drive to be mounted above the boom, and away from the steering arm.

I think the hub motor will get tried first.
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,531
3,277