KTM Corner

EddiePJ

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jul 7, 2013
4,632
4,013
Crowborough, East Sussex
www.facebook.com
Is the "crud catcher" an off the shelf product Eddie?
The crud catcher is just an old Topeak front mudguard that was laying around.

I'm going to be investigating having a small batch run of custom mudguards made at some stage, and will keep all updated about it. Other than the mucknutz front guard, I've yet to find a set that tick all of boxes.

In respect of the battery, I'm just currently lucky enough to have two batteries around to use.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bigclick

EddiePJ

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jul 7, 2013
4,632
4,013
Crowborough, East Sussex
www.facebook.com
The Bullet guard.

After the other nights complete and utter drenching in mud and water, and returning with a Camelbak that could no longer be recognized, I figured that I had best sort my loathing for mudguards out, and finish the Macina Lycan specific guard out.
Tomorrow will see it's first trial run, so hopefully it will perform okay. Not having enough plastic to from it one, actually worked out better, as I now have a quickly detachable end section. I have still managed to retain approx. 40mm of clearance at the tightest point to the rear tyre, and suspension is able to operate without hindrance. Pretty it isn't, but hopefully it'll work as and when I need it.





 
Last edited:

EddiePJ

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jul 7, 2013
4,632
4,013
Crowborough, East Sussex
www.facebook.com
That question was put to me sometime last week, and then as now I hesitate to answer. :)

I really should know straight from the top of my head but don't. I was hoping to get another ride on a Panasonic hub drive bike to make a direct comparison. It's surprising how quickly that you forget and or get used to things.
In truth I'd love to own both, and hopefully one day I shall. Both have their place, and both probably have their plus and minus points. The Performance line Bosch motor doesn't seem anywhere near as good on range when compared to the old classic line, but as the name implies, it does appear to have more performance, is less lethargic in taking off, and is far quieter and smoother. The Panasonic hub will undoubtedly give more battery range, and I would imagine be far smoother and even quieter. It should also require less effort to ride for an equal gain in certain situations. I was very unsure of crank drives when I first used one, but I do love the feeling of having a work out when I ride, which is something less achievable with the hub drive.

Actually, as I'm writing this, it doesn't sit comfortably comparing the two, without having the hub drive for direct comparison. I feel as though I'm going to end up making up crap, without being able to back up the statements.

I wouldn't hesitate in recommending either set up, but if you are already happy with the Panasonic hub drive and know it well, then perhaps sticking with it would be the sensible option. :)

You have made me want a Panasonic hub drive even more now. As a second bike, I could be very tempted by an eRACE P 27 or even an eSTREET P especially now that they come with the larger battery pack.
 

Staffordshirehills

Pedelecer
Aug 28, 2014
88
25
55
Thanks Eddie for this. I have fallen hook line and sinker for ebikes thanks to the KTM. This offer from Colin seems a good buy and we are really undecided as to whether to try something just that little bit different. I guess they are all very good machines.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TinKitten

EddiePJ

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jul 7, 2013
4,632
4,013
Crowborough, East Sussex
www.facebook.com
I like both forms of motor now, and in respect of Cols offer, looking at it another way. If worse comes to worse and you don't like it, you always have something to sell. I very much doubt that you would end up taking a loss on it, or if you did, I can't imagine it being very much. :)
 

Wicky

Esteemed Pedelecer
Feb 12, 2014
2,823
4,011
Colchester, Essex
www.jhepburn.co.uk
I got my ex-demo eRace P 29 in late May with a similar milage at a very good price and now done almost 700 miles on top of that without any problems - well there was one, a dinked rim, but Colin & Tom at FLI resolved it. I'd recommend a KTM - a bit like an Apple Mac over a PC!

Just make sure you look it over thoroughly in case anything got missed on its last service.
 

Staffordshirehills

Pedelecer
Aug 28, 2014
88
25
55
Thanks Eddie and Wicky, I have the e cross p and so far it has been wonderful. Would the bosch motor feel similar? What sort of distance do you think it would be good for or is it mainly for off roading? (We will do lots of hills and some off road). Thanks.
 

EddiePJ

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jul 7, 2013
4,632
4,013
Crowborough, East Sussex
www.facebook.com
Frustratingly I genuingly can't remember how the two motors compare. :(

I guess that this must actually be a very positive, or it would highlight that one once better than the other. I remember that the Bosch motor was an acquired taste, but that was with the older motor. The newer motor feels quite refined.
I don't believe that you will be disappointed if you were to buy it, but it might take a short time to get used to it. If only you had been closer, as I'd happily have let you try my bike.
Distance is a very tricky one to answer and is very subjective. Arguably, I'd say that the Panasonic would give you greater distance, but there are so many variables. Todays ride for example was 26 miles, and I have only used half of the battery. Last week, I had flattened the battery by this mileage. Sorry that my reply perhaps couldn't be more helpful. :)

And speaking of todays ride...
Perfect weather, perfect bike. :)




After 26miles this is the battery level from today's ride. Admittedly, I used non assist a fair bit, and when using assist, it was mainly eco, with the odd bit of tour thrown in. As said before, the bike rides surprisingly well in non assist mode.

 
Last edited:

Wander

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 8, 2013
586
429
What sort of distance do you think it would be good for or is it mainly for off roading? (We will do lots of hills and some off road). Thanks.
I'd echo Eddie's comments above. I have a Bosch Gen 1 & up to now I've been doing some fairly tough (for me!) off road stuff in hilly areas. I'd tend to get 25 - 30 miles out of a 400wh battery.

Yesterday however did my first 'road trip'. Same sort of hilly areas but this time on roads only with the tyres pumped up to 50 p.s.i. Did 32 miles & still had 17 miles range left at the finish.

So many factors influence range, hills, terrain, personal fitness, personal weight, what level of assistance you select, tyre pressure etc. etc.
 

trev

Finding my (electric) wheels
Sep 19, 2012
9
1
Brief update on my lovely KTM erace P650, bought in June 2013. It gave about 1500 miles excellent service. Superb hill climbing, well balanced, decent range - overall a magnificent bike, and hugely better in every way to my previous ebike, the BH emotion Neo Cross, which really didn't like rain.

Sadly the KTM's Panasonic motor destroyed itself about two months ago. Col at FLI was helpful, saying the warranty remains valid even though the shop I bought it from went out of business, and I'm sure he shares my frustration that after two months we seem to be no nearer getting a replacement, leaving my beautiful bike uselessly stuck in the garage. :(

I don't suppose anyone knows of any spare Panasonic hubs lying around (doesn't need to be new)?
 
HI Trev.

Just to update you... normally there would be a dealer in place to help you with a spare bike / loan a hub or simply fix the fault or something like that. That's what they are there for. In this case as your dealer has gone bust that step is missing.

We would normally have taken a hub out of one of our demo bikes, to see you though the few weeks a warranty can take.

However in this case I'm afraid we sold our demo bikes after the NEC show an the 2015 ones have been delayed a bit... so there is nothing here we can even lend you to get your bike on the road.

We're chasing for news and will come back to you via normal communication channels as soon as we have something.

Regards
Tom
 
Last edited:

Artstu

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 2, 2009
2,420
925
It gave about 1500 miles excellent service.

Sadly the KTM's Panasonic motor destroyed itself about two months ago.
Sorry to hear that. It certainly doesn't inspire confidence in the Panasonic hub.
 

RobF

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 22, 2012
4,732
2,312
Sorry to hear that. It certainly doesn't inspire confidence in the Panasonic hub.
Agreed.

And it's the usual 'we'd like to help but...' response from FLI.

I know asking this is tantamount to blasphemy, but why does the importer not have any spares?

A couple of Panasonic wheels would seem a sensible move.

Not to mention forks, as mentioned in another thread.

So what if it ties up a few hundred quid?

Cost of being in business, I'm afraid.

As an example, the Oxygen importer keeps a handful of spare motor wheels at their premises in Yorkshire.

They also keep other spares such as controllers, spokes, looms, etc.

No doubt, KTM/FLI see themselves as a far superior brand to the cheapie Chinese importers at Oxygen.

KTMs cost more, break, and you can't get spares.

Oxygens cost less, break, and the importer will put a spare in the post same day.

Which brand is offering the best customer experience?
 
Agreed.

And it's the usual 'we'd like to help but...' response from FLI.
Hi Rob,

We came on here to offer an input to the forum from a brands perspective and all brands have slightly different perspectives... so I'll try to give ours so you have some insight into some of your comments.

Firstly, our response is always "we'll do our best to help" and of course in some cases there is a 'but'... however in the vast majority there isn't.

I can give you an example today of a customer (who bought their KTM from LEBC) that has cracked the lowers on their Suntour forks. The dealer, us and Suntour all agreed this was caused by the qr not being used properly by the customer, so it wasn't a manufacturing fault. However Tom from here negotiated with Suntour to get a new set of lowers and a new QR sent to the dealer by Suntour and LEBC are swapping them over as a good will gesture. All this sorted within a few days, by the customer / dealer and us going though the correct channels. No issues and we hope everyone is happy.

I know asking this is tantamount to blasphemy, but why does the importer not have any spares?

A couple of Panasonic wheels would seem a sensible move.

Not to mention forks, as mentioned in another thread.

So what if it ties up a few hundred quid?

Cost of being in business, I'm afraid.
Its a fair question, but some quick points to help you understand.

The forks, you're talking about were in Ireland, so not something we know about, but as far as we can see the customer should have just gone back to the shop and they would have been sorted.

With regard to the points that are more directly aimed at us.

We're not an importer, all the bikes are shipped by KTM direct to the dealers.

In the whole time we've worked with KTM, we've not had a single hub fail, so holding spare wheels isn't a sensible business move I'm afraid.

We do hold some spares... Bosch batteries and head units for instance, because we do know these occasionally get error codes and it helps our dealers for us to have stock, just in case they, or Bosch don't.

However across the range of 240 bikes that we sell, there isn't really any other part that has failed more than once that I can think off of the top of my head. Even if it had, us holding stock in the UK wouldn;t really help, because in 99% of cases its the dealers role to fix or provide a spare whilst we / KTM sort the replacement or credit note.

So if we decided to hold spare parts for all 240 different bikes in the range in all sizes and colours the cost wouldn't be a couple of hundred quid, it would be hundreds of thousands and 99% of it would be a total waste of time.

We normally have at least 5 KTM Pananoic eBikes in stock for demo purposes, and even my fiance and our northern rep's wife both had Panasonic eBikes, so in normal circumstances we'd just send one of these bikes to this customer whilst he waits for his hub to be fixed. However demand from our dealers has been so high over the past 3 months because we haven't got the 2015 panasonic bikes yet, that these have all been sold.

The demo bikes we hold are a massive investment from us, and if there is ever a case that a dealer can't help a customer and the spare parts from KTM are a while off there is normally something we can do.

As an example, the Oxygen importer keeps a handful of spare motor wheels at their premises in Yorkshire.

They also keep other spares such as controllers, spokes, looms, etc.
Again you appear to be slightly comparing apples and pears.

Oxygen in the UK, dont appear to be distributors... they are the brand, so can be compared to KTM in Austria not to us really.

KTMs cost more, break, and you can't get spares.

Oxygens cost less, break, and the importer will put a spare in the post same day.

Which brand is offering the best customer experience?
KTM's and indeed any brand can break of course... we provide many spares within 48 hours from the huge warehouse in Austria, and dealers get them very quickly. There are a couple of examples on here that have taken longer, but I'm afraid if you look on any cycling forum any major brand of bikes with 100+ models struggles to hold stock or all spares in all sizes for all bikes, and we can't be any different, so sometimes it takes time. Which is why we only work with quality components that have their own service centres in the UK, and equally why we try to work with the best dealers who have their own stock of spares and even demo bikes they can lend out.

We're not trying to make excuses, and we're always trying to improve, but we hope we can go way to explaining things on here from time to time.

Col
 

RobF

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 22, 2012
4,732
2,312
So I'm confusing the importer/maker am I?

Let's put it simply, FLI should have access to spares.

KTM in Austria should be able to send you any spare you don't have in 24 hours.

It's Austria, not another galaxy, far, far away.

There is simply no coherent service back up, that's a simple matter of fact.

It's made worse by the fact that FLI/KTM is not unusual.

The bike makers/brands/importers have been treating the customer terribly for years - it is ingrained, it is the way most of you do what you laughingly call business.

There are exceptional cases where service is better, and no doubt some makers/importers are less worse than others.

But generally, the bike industry is light years behind other retail businesses when it comes to service.
 
I can't argue with many of your points, and we do have access to a huge amount of spares, from over 100 suppliers, but they aren't always all in stock. I've been on the other side of the fence as a cycling customer for nearly 25 years now, so I do appreciate the frustration.

The problem is no one in the bike industry is making millions... that I know of. So there is no point in the supply chain that can say... yes we'll hold stock of every spare for every bike in every size / colour at all times. Its hard enough to keep stock of things people want to buy.

For instance, KTM might have all the hubs for instance, they might just be waiting for a small part for it for a small Far Easten cog manufacturer who makes the cogs... but they might be waiting for the raw material. I'm not sure.

So its a staged approach. I'll use myself as an example.

I'm a cyclist... and I ride a lot. So I keep some spares.

Tyres, mech hangers, chains, cables, brake pads etc etc in my own workshop because these often need replacing.

Other things that need replacing or brake on a less regular basis I'd expect my local bike shop to have, or I'd use one of the massive on-line retail guys who can afford to hold stock to source one.

So in this case, if I was to buy an eBike, one of the first things I'd be researching is the bike... then the dealer. Because there are many eBike dealers who can fix all problems in house and have spares. However in this case the dealer has gone bust so rather than leave the customer high and dry we're sorting it. Its just not an immediate fix.

If forks, break for instance - which has happened to me a lot. I went though 8 sets of Manitous in one season once... I'd not expect the shop to have stock, I'd expect the importer to hold the stock. But I'd appreciate that I might have to wait a bit. But I suppose that comes from my time working in bike shops that I have an understanding of things.

I've broken a few frames over the years, SantaCruz / Yeti / Orange and others. In some cases its been replaced in a week, I had to wait 12 months for one of them! In another case because I was desperate I took a different colour part for my frame which looked a mess, but as I was just interested in getting to races it didn't bother me.

Now I work for a major brand, I know how many millions of parts KTM hold in stock. But they can't hold everything at all the times... if they'd done that, they'd have gone bust. They've been making bikes for 50 years so thats a lot of parts for a lot of different bikes to hold in stock!

But yes we're working to constantly improve, and in most case - yes... KTM ship to a dealer within 48 hours. We use UPS so its a 48hr service from Austria to the shop.
 

Advertisers