Upping by budget for an ebike. But which one?

[KPNUTS#]

Hello all,

I am buying a new bike and after much deliberation about a woosh rio mountain bike and an oxygen MTB, I have decided to up my budget from £1500 to £2500ish and likely go for one of the following


https://www.evanscycles.com/haibike-sduro-cross-4-0-2017-electric-hybrid-bike-EV299278


http://www.50cycles.com/electric-bikes/giant-bikes/road_e-2_2016.html


What do you guys think?


I will be mostly commuting to work and back every day on roads, close to 40 miles round trip.

I do have a concern with the Yamaha motor which is on both bikes though, as it doesn't have shift sensing and can wear the gears/chain However, the giant bike has Giant PedalPlus 4-sensor technology, which I think is similar to the bosch shift sensing and turns down the power slightly when changing gear. Correct me if I'm wrong on this?

Any help or suggestions with other bikes would be greatly appreciated.


many thanks

 

[GLJoe]

I do have a concern with the Yamaha motor which is on both bikes though, as it doesn't have shift sensing

Personally, I'd ignore that factor in your decision making process.

 

[KPNUTS#]

Personally, I'd ignore that factor in your decision making process.

But what are your reasons to ignore please? Is the yamaha just as good? Does it not cause a lot more wear and crunching?

 

[Woosh]

if you want a good CD motor, the CX is difficult to beat, runner up is the Shimano Steps 8000.

 

[KPNUTS#]

if you want a good CD motor, the CX is difficult to beat, runner up is the Shimano Steps 8000.

Thanks. Can you recommend any bikes of a similar price with these motors?

 

[GLJoe]

But what are your reasons to ignore please? Is the yamaha just as good? Does it not cause a lot more wear and crunching?

So far, I've not noticed any significant difference in the crunching between the Yamaha and the Bosch (although that is riding sensibly and knocking back the leg power as you're changing gear as you're suppose to do anyway).
I can certainly get my Bosch bike to give just as crunchy gear changes as my wifes Yamaha! There is no dedicated 'shift sensor' anywhere in the gear change mechanism/drive, unlike some systems where there is a switch connected to the gear cable.

 

[Deleted member 4366]

Don't forget that the Yamaha is the only one that can be derestricted without a dongle. that saves you £130.

 

[KPNUTS#]

Don't forget that the Yamaha is the only one that can be derestricted without a dongle. that saves you £130.

Hmmm. Very interesting!That does make a difference (if I decided to do that). (Off road /private land of course). Is it easy to do? Is it just a case of moving the sensor and magnet to the pedals instead of the wheel? Or is there another way I can easily switch between the two? On/off switch.

Out of interest, which bike would you choose? The giant or the haibike?

 

[Crockers]

Don't forget that the Yamaha is the only one that can be derestricted without a dongle. that saves you £130.

I'm sure that's the last thing on anyone's mind

 

[soundwave]

i doubt the magnet on the pedal trick wont work on the giant as it is there own software\ system.

https://www.ebiketuning.com/

 

[KPNUTS#]

i doubt the magnet on the pedal trick wont work on the giant as it is there own software\ system.

https://www.ebiketuning.com/

So on that basis would you choose the haibike?

 

[soundwave]

i have a haibike with a bad ass dongle but the giant will limit you to road riding only.

if you want warranty and a dongle then only ebike shop will do this and fit it for 150 quid

 

[KPNUTS#]

i have a haibike with a bad ass dongle but the giant will limit you to road riding only.

if you want warranty and a dongle then only ebike shop will do this and fit it for 150 quid

That does sound temping. Is it really easy to switch between road legal and derestricted at a flick of a button so to speak? I have heard the police are clamping down in certain areas and have a means to check your bike?

 

[soundwave]

some dongles have a on and off button via the light button and some have the right mph on the screen or like my badd ass dongle shows half speed but can be removed in seconds.

the police are not interested round here.

 

[Deleted member 4366]

If you have the Yamaha motor, moving the sensor and the magnet works. Giant call the Yamaha their Syncdrive, but it's no different to a Yamaha on any other bike is it?

 

[soundwave]

If you have the Yamaha motor, moving the sensor and the magnet works. Giant call the Yamaha their Syncdrive, but it's no different to a Yamaha on any other bike is it?

gubbins has one maybe he could give it a try n see if it works or not tho i bet i wont but you never know until its been proven one way or the other.

 

[Deleted member 4366]

He's already done it, but he doesn't want to tell anyone. My bike's restricted too.

 

[nemesis]

Hello all,

I am buying a new bike and after much deliberation about a woosh rio mountain bike and an oxygen MTB, I have decided to up my budget from £1500 to £2500ish and likely go for one of the following


https://www.evanscycles.com/haibike-sduro-cross-4-0-2017-electric-hybrid-bike-EV299278


http://www.50cycles.com/electric-bikes/giant-bikes/road_e-2_2016.html


What do you guys think?


I will be mostly commuting to work and back every day on roads, close to 40 miles round trip.

I do have a concern with the Yamaha motor which is on both bikes though, as it doesn't have shift sensing and can wear the gears/chain However, the giant bike has Giant PedalPlus 4-sensor technology, which I think is similar to the bosch shift sensing and turns down the power slightly when changing gear. Correct me if I'm wrong on this?

Any help or suggestions with other bikes would be greatly appreciated.


many thanks

Winstanleys bikes in Wigan are doing the 2016 Giant road E+2 for £1799.

 

[Solarbake]

Winstanleys bikes in Wigan are doing the 2016 Giant road E+2 for £1799.

Either bike would be nice,i do the same commute 40 mile round trip and your def need it derestricted either with dongle or the magnet trick as you will find it too slow,i have a kalkhoff bs10 which is a speed pedelec 45km/h it is 3,5 years old now but still working well.Its up to 14000 miles on it now,but it's just been recelled by jimmy at BGA with a 14ah battery
and it's unbelievable now with range and power.
I do each half of the trip in well under an hour.Normally 55 minutes and the same trip driving ranges from 35-45 minutes depending on traffic.
Enjoy whatever you get.

 

[KPNUTS#]

I went for the haibike in the end. Managed to get it for £1890 with ebikes direct. (originally £2100. So pretty good price.

I will derestrict myself though. Looks pretty easy on youtube