Tongsheng vlcd5

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
20,917
8,533
61
West Sx RH
Can anyone tell me the available parameters viewable on the screen, for instance does it have a voltage readout like the KT lcd3 ?
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,424
3,247
Looking through the manual, it doesn't seem to. Mentions a voltage display with blocks representing 25%.
 

JohnE

Just Joined
Apr 7, 2021
3
0
Standard firmware displays assist level, speed, voltage in the form of 6 bars, and Cumulative distance (odometer, ODO); Trip distance (TRIP); Average speed (AVG); Single trip time (TIME).

I've only read the manual, not installed it (yet), but there is a branch of the Open Source Firmware for the VLCD5 which flashes the motor firmware, and if I've read it right, can be configured to display any 6 of the following parameters :-

0 – motor temperature, only with sensor installed (° C)
1 - remaining battery charge (%)
2 - battery voltage (Volt)
3 - battery current (Amp)
4 - power absorbed by the motor (Watt / 10)
5 - throttle adc value (8 bit)
6 - torque sensor adc value (10 bit)
7 - pedal cadence (rpm)
8 - human power (Watt / 10)
9 - torque sensor range (10 bit)
10- consumed Wh
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
20,917
8,533
61
West Sx RH
Ok, so answer is no.
No issues then I would wire up a separate volt meter.
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,424
3,247
Blocks representing 25% voltage seems utterly useless, unless you know what what max and min voltages are being represented. I don't know about this display, but open source/non-original or non-approved firmware can:

1. "Brick" devices if a firmware write goes badly (complete replacement of firmware).

2. Somewhat "Brick" the device if the open source code (or compiled using open source or third party code) is updating configuration of firmware (or "patching" some specific parts of firmware) with values it doesn't accept, triggering a crash or programmed shutdown.

In the second case(s), it may be possible to reset it (seller or manufacturer). For the first case, the manufacturer may have tools to rewrite with the original firmware, if a firmware write using third party code has gone badly. It's fine if whatever device you are trying to write to is cheap to replace, or you enjoy experimentation, or know there's a good chance that it'll work.

For instance, the seller of my BBS01b controller which I killed (controller, not the seller), has offered to reset the firmware using a software tool he has, because he's convinced that I have bricked the controller by changing it's configuration using a programming cable. The horrible burning smell makes me suspect he's angling for a warranty exception, but I'd have to post it to China to find out for sure. I'm debating whether boiling or steaming off the silicone which covers the controller board, to attempt removal of mosfets to keep as spares, would be a better option.
 
Last edited:

tonyw

Pedelecer
Jun 21, 2019
34
15
For instance, the seller of my BBS01b controller which I killed (controller, not the seller), has offered to reset the firmware using a software tool he has, because he's convinced that I have bricked the controller by changing it's configuration using a programming cable.
That seems quite reasonable to me - I think pretty much any product, if you flash it with 3rd party firmware, that would void the warranty. Re the vlcd05, yes the display is pretty basic, just speed, trip, odo etc, and a basic idea of battery charge. But that's been all I've really needed to use the bike. The additional info listed above doesn't look that useful unless you want to play with the parameters with the open source firmware. If you want a better idea of battery voltage, power etc. then I think you can get separate meters to measure those vales I think?
 

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
20,917
8,533
61
West Sx RH
One reason why I like the KT lcd3 and 4 is because the voltage readout is accurate and part of the main basic screen functions, voltage readout is worth 10x more then a simple battery status bar one can't rely on for accuracy.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bikes4two

Bikes4two

Esteemed Pedelecer
Feb 21, 2020
1,009
433
Havant
The simple to use java Configurator that works alongside the OSF (open Source Firmware) offers the ability to display certain parameters (as mentioned by @JohnE above). I've only lightly tinkered with this function for my VLCD6 display but haven't as yet got it to work - but I'm not bothered anyway.
44786
Whilst flashing firmware on microcontrollers (and mobile phones etc) can be fraught and leading to the 'bricking' (making useless) the device in question, I read long and hard about OSF on the TSDZ2 (which uses the VLCD5, VLCD6 and XH18 displays) and never once did I read of the microcontroller being bricked using the well rehearsed procedures given in the thread on this forum by @Swizz here and many other people/places.

Flashing the TSDZ2 firmware whilst not for complete technophobes, is not difficult either.
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,424
3,247
That seems quite reasonable to me - I think pretty much any product, if you flash it with 3rd party firmware, that would void the warranty. Re the vlcd05, yes the display is pretty basic, just speed, trip, odo etc, and a basic idea of battery charge. But that's been all I've really needed to use the bike. The additional info listed above doesn't look that useful unless you want to play with the parameters with the open source firmware. If you want a better idea of battery voltage, power etc. then I think you can get separate meters to measure those vales I think?
wWell - I've sent my controller to China, at a cost of £20... in transit... I've got to know. If bricked, it'll likely be due to the trash "Retrofit" for lights kit I tried to install, shortly before the controller stopped working. Prior to that, my last update via USB was in April, although that still doesn't discount bricking by third party code. The burning smell could have been the controller or the retrofit kit. We shall see.... (if the seller actually bothers to inspect it).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bikes4two

Bikes4two

Esteemed Pedelecer
Feb 21, 2020
1,009
433
Havant
wWell - I've sent my controller to China, at a cost of £20... in transit... I've got to know. If bricked, it'll likely be due to the trash "Retrofit" for lights kit I tried to install, shortly before the controller stopped working. Prior to that, my last update via USB was in April, although that still doesn't discount bricking by third party code. The burning smell could have been the controller or the retrofit kit. We shall see.... (if the seller actually bothers to inspect it).
Re the lights: Out of interest were these 6v lights being powered from the 'lights' 'Y' connector shared with the speed sensor? I've read several times that this power source is only good for around 0.5 amps which gives a total lighting power of just 3 watts. Thus if your lights were more than 3w, then the controller has likely been damaged.
 
  • Like
Reactions: guerney

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,424
3,247
Re the lights: Out of interest were these 6v lights being powered from the 'lights' 'Y' connector shared with the speed sensor? I've read several times that this power source is only good for around 0.5 amps which gives a total lighting power of just 3 watts. Thus if your lights were more than 3w, then the controller has likely been damaged.
Hey that's good to know! Here is an account of the whole sorry saga (it's a little long, but has a happy ending).


device used:

 
Last edited:

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,424
3,247
That seems quite reasonable to me - I think pretty much any product, if you flash it with 3rd party firmware, that would void the warranty. Re the vlcd05, yes the display is pretty basic, just speed, trip, odo etc, and a basic idea of battery charge. But that's been all I've really needed to use the bike. The additional info listed above doesn't look that useful unless you want to play with the parameters with the open source firmware. If you want a better idea of battery voltage, power etc. then I think you can get separate meters to measure those vales I think?
I fear it might have been a complete waste of £20 posting the controller to the seller in China - he's playing for time, having had it for over a week. Keeps saying things like "The Bafang engineers are very busy"... I very much wanted to know what the specific issue was: Was it hardware failure? Or was the fault due to the installation of third party firmware? I haven't written a full review of the kit I bought on Amazon yet, but based on how this plays out... this final part of my review will be mentioned with significant emphasis. It's within the warranty perid, the controller should be repaired or replaced. The speed limit wasn't changed, so he can't complain about that - still a legal 15mph, when it died emitting a burning smell. 15A as originally.
 
Last edited:

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,424
3,247
That seems quite reasonable to me - I think pretty much any product, if you flash it with 3rd party firmware, that would void the warranty. Re the vlcd05, yes the display is pretty basic, just speed, trip, odo etc, and a basic idea of battery charge. But that's been all I've really needed to use the bike. The additional info listed above doesn't look that useful unless you want to play with the parameters with the open source firmware. If you want a better idea of battery voltage, power etc. then I think you can get separate meters to measure those vales I think?
The seller is now promising to send me a new controller next week, when they receive one (lol, what are the chances that they can't get new controllers because of "Supply" problems?), bacause the controller I returned to them for repair has "Serious damage to the programming and wiring". If a mosfet or some other component has failed (I did smell something burning, and there was a small brown area of the silicone which looked like something had burned underneath, possibly a mosfet?), they can't check the pogramming without repairing that anyway, which I doubt that they'd bother doing, because it'd mean excavating the electronic components from the silicone somehow (possibly by dissolving it). So I'll never know for sure if third party firmware caused the problem. It's a waste of £20 postage, unless they ever send me a new controller. It'd be nice to have a spare.
 
Last edited:

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,424
3,247
That seems quite reasonable to me - I think pretty much any product, if you flash it with 3rd party firmware, that would void the warranty. Re the vlcd05, yes the display is pretty basic, just speed, trip, odo etc, and a basic idea of battery charge. But that's been all I've really needed to use the bike. The additional info listed above doesn't look that useful unless you want to play with the parameters with the open source firmware. If you want a better idea of battery voltage, power etc. then I think you can get separate meters to measure those vales I think?
Alas, I shall never know if it was firmware which borked my controller - after sending the seller a very long series of extremely angry looking emails threatening truly epic negative feedback on Amazon for both product and seller, he emailed me a tracking number for a brand new controller (free). Just hope I don't get stung by customs, if it appears. I should have kept the dead controller and attempted to answer the question for myself.
 
Last edited:

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,424
3,247
That seems quite reasonable to me - I think pretty much any product, if you flash it with 3rd party firmware, that would void the warranty. Re the vlcd05, yes the display is pretty basic, just speed, trip, odo etc, and a basic idea of battery charge. But that's been all I've really needed to use the bike. The additional info listed above doesn't look that useful unless you want to play with the parameters with the open source firmware. If you want a better idea of battery voltage, power etc. then I think you can get separate meters to measure those vales I think?
I've received a brand new replacement controller from China, free, no tax or duty charges (also no gasket). I'm surprised that a seller based in China honoured their guarantee. I did have to threaten to write highly negative reviews on Amazon in both product and seller sections (Amazon don't allow any mention of the seller in the product section), before he brought forward the dispatch date from a vague "Next week", to "The warehouse has already dispatched it". Now that I have the security of a spare controller, I can experiment freely with the one I bought from greenbikekit.com... but I'll never know if firmware config bricked the first controller. I was really hoping they'd do a full diagnostic test, but I suppose it wasn't worth their while. The 12 month guarantee runs out next week.
 
Last edited: