You could try a shunt mod then. Take the end-plate off the controller, where hopefully you'll see the shunt grinning at you and begging for a drop of solder. It looks a bit like a thick staple. The idea is to add some solder on one side about 25% of the entire length, which will increase your power by 25%. You can't go any higher than that. There are other things you can do, but they all involve spending increasingly more money. Try the solder first.
If you're unsure about where the shunt is, show us a photo inside the controller.
I'm pretty sure that your present motor can give you the power you need. it's the controller that's limiting it at the moment.