The best pedelec (for me anyway)

CDinFrance

Finding my (electric) wheels
Dec 9, 2008
19
0
Last Saturday the research and testing finally ended, and the payments began...

I am the proud owner of a Villiger Levantina E (one of the first I think)



This bike is certainly not for everybody, but I think it is the best available for my needs and riding style.

Tech: Bionx 250W 40.7 volt 6.4Ah Lithium battery. Aluminum frame 25.9Kg.

Style: I am a fairly energetic rider, and just want to make a 5 mile urban commute a little more pleasurable by flattening the (10-20%) hills.

Ebike History: I rode a Yamaha Easy Super (great pedelec!) for 7 years until it was stolen last fall/

Things I like:

Upright riding position - much like a Dutch bike - it makes me feel safe in traffic.

Simple efficient gearing - 8 speed derailleur - no need for more

True pedelec - very smooth controller that feels like a natural 'push'

Quiet - rear motor is basically inaudible - to the rider anyway...

Regen braking - not for the battery charging - it just feels smooth and reassuring - and saves brake pads

Hill climbing - OK the max I have is 20% but it eats these up - on level 4 - high gear and 25kph!

General finish - Villiger are excellent quality bikes - with excellent service

Confidence in the Bionx system - which seems to have proven itself to be reliable

Minuses:

25 kph limit - still waiting for a software crack - the EU regulations have closed all the other Bionx workarounds. But I found that I can work around it. A) on level 2, the 'wall' is much more subtle B) setting the gearing right, I can reach a natural cadence of about 70 rpm and stay just below the 25 kph max on the flat.

Swiss - high price - 3200 CHF - and only available in Switzerland - Villiger is owned by Trek though, but Trek doesn't offer this model (only similar ones with 24 gears) and can only be found in Holland so far.

Other bikes I tested:

All Kalkhoff and Raleigh models
Flyer high end models
Giant twist express
Gazelle Orange innergy
Koga Tesla
Wattworld - E-Move Evolution

For more pictures see:

http://www.photoshop.com/user/craigduncan/?wf=share&trackingid=BTAGC&galleryid=cbbd47d65c024f30abba6ce0cec55a28

I will do another report after a few hundred kilometers.
 

flecc

Member
Oct 25, 2006
53,152
30,567
Thanks for the info CDinFrance.

Looks a very nice bike, lots of quality showing, and the refinement and reputation for reliability of the BionX is
good. An unusually good gearset for a rear motor bike too.
.
 

Barnowl

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 18, 2008
954
1
Very nice looking bike. I especially like the rack and battery arrangement.
 

Django

Esteemed Pedelecer
Feb 11, 2007
453
1
Hill climbing - OK the max I have is 20% but it eats these up - on level 4 - high gear and 25kph!
Hey, don't knock 20%. That is almost twice as steep as Richmond Park? :D

Seriously though, it looks great. I would be interested to know why you chose it over the other bikes you tested.
 

lectureral

Esteemed Pedelecer
Apr 30, 2007
397
60
Suva, Fiji
I bought in Switzerland as well - a Raleigh Leicester - and the price was about the same - difference was that then the £1 bought 2 Swiss Francs and now it is 1.71 (was 1.56 at the turn of the year). Any way you look at it Switzerland is expensive at the moment.