Seeking Advice on Affordable Ebike for 20-Mile Daily Commute (£500-£600 = Budget)

Nealh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 7, 2014
20,981
8,565
61
West Sx RH
The low price point may end up being an achilles heel esp for the regular 20 mile commute, reliability may be an issue if you aren't maintenance savvy. The electric operating system is likely to be a very basic one .
 

egroover

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 12, 2016
1,050
635
57
UK
Surely a £500 ebay bike is gonna have cheaper/inferior quality components that are gonna fail quicker doing 5k miles per year ?
That's a lot of winter miles that can punish a bike, I know, did a 12 mile commute every day in all weathers for 5 years
 
  • Like
Reactions: Woosh

saneagle

Esteemed Pedelecer
Oct 10, 2010
7,005
3,241
Telford
Surely a £500 ebay bike is gonna have cheaper/inferior quality components that are gonna fail quicker doing 5k miles per year ?
That's a lot of winter miles that can punish a bike, I know, did a 12 mile commute every day in all weathers for 5 years
I wouldn't say that. What do you think would fail and how? The electrical parts those bikes use have been around for ten years. The rest of the parts are all standard bike parts. A replacement battery would cost about £150 to £200. Compare that with the cost of a Bosch or shimano battery, or even a Halfords one. What about the £1300 for a KTM E-Cross battery if you can find one.

Quite often the more expensive parts are less durable because they're lightweight. The only parts I've had to replace on my bike in 10 years apart from chainsaws batteries are cables and chainwheels for my deluxe Shimano XT gears. I never had to replace gear parts on my previous commuter bikes with cheapo Tourney gears or worse.

I did a winter soak test on a cheap catalogue bike that I rescued from a tip and paid £5 for to test the theory that cheap bikes fail. It did 1000 miles in snow, sleet, rain and salt with no cleaning or maintenance. It could have done 5000 miles if I'd asked it to.
 
Last edited:
  • Informative
Reactions: robert44

Az.

Esteemed Pedelecer
Apr 27, 2022
2,092
932
Plymouth
When I think about cheap bikes, first thing which comes to my mind is rust. Rust on almost each component. I guess it is because most owners of cheap bikes don't care about them... or anything else for that matter. But also quality of components must contribute to general decay as well.
My Weber BBQ after 15 years still looks good while Tower smoker is all rusty after one year. I guess you get what you are paying for.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Woosh

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,531
3,277
Why bother buying rubbish you'd have to repair or upgrade, shortly after purchase? If I had a budget of £600, I'd take a punt on a Bafang 36V 250W BBS01B kit from PSW Power for £300.28, then get the best battery deal I could (without skimping by buying cheap Chinese celled [false economy]), and a decent secondhand bike from ebay, Gumtree or Faceache marketplace etc. Faceache in particular appears to be a buyer's market. You can get a lot more bang for your buck buying a secondhand bike. My bike's an old folding bike from 2006: 36V 250W BBS01B converted and it rides great, hauls heavy trailers up hills with ease, zooms along fast on flat roads.

But a KT hub motor kit will be cheaper - they reportedly last for many years, and are cheaper to repair.


54347

 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: egroover and Az.

peterjd

Pedelecer
Sep 18, 2019
213
52
perhaps someone should mention the price premium charged for replacement batteries in a custom form to fit an integral frame mount if available at all.
The extreme example being the recent post regarding a ktm battery circa £1.5k with 20% off iirc..
Decathlon batteries are reasonable at £279 for my 500E bike, but I might be looking to recell after the 2 year warranty period. Hopefully long after 2 years:)
 
Last edited:

cyclebuddy

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 2, 2016
1,640
771
Beds & Norfolk
I like @Peter.Bridge 's suggestion of the Eleglide Citycrosser at £599. It's got all the extra bits @Woosh mentioned in post #20 for a commute (mudguards, stand, front light, 700c puncture-proof tyres, even a front rack), rapid-fire 7-speed Shimano gears (presumably Tourney, but nothing wrong with that), and a 10Ah battery that should manage a 20 mile commute... and it claims a proper torque sensor too. I think it looks pretty respectable, and that's an amazing discount/bargain. Not sure if that's a Dorado battery, but I saw replacement 36v/10Ah ones for £220ish somewhere. EDIT: Looking further into this, Eleglide have a UK/EU warehouse and offer a quite good range of essential spares for this bike here. A spare 36v 10Ah battery is £202.

Sure, we'd all prefer a £2000+ Cube or something better if we had the choice and budget, but we're not all that lucky. Maybe upgrade the brakes to hydraulic for £40, but the existing mechanical discs would do the job fine at least to start with.

There's a Van-dweller on Youtube running an Eleglide bike long term, and he loves it.

54373
 
Last edited:

Peter.Bridge

Esteemed Pedelecer
Apr 19, 2023
1,328
609
I like @Peter.Bridge 's suggestion of the Eleglide Citycrosser at £599. It's got all the extra bits @Woosh mentioned in post #20 for a commute (mudguards, stand, front light, 700c puncture-proof tyres, even a front rack), rapid-fire 7-speed Shimano gears (presumably Tourney, but nothing wrong with that), and a 10Ah battery that should manage a 20 mile commute... and it claims a proper torque sensor too. I think it looks pretty respectable, and that's an amazing discount/bargain. Not sure if that's a Dorado battery, but I saw replacement 36v/10Ah ones for £220ish somewhere. EDIT: Looking further into this, Eleglide have a UK/EU warehouse and offer a quite good range of essential spares for this bike here. A spare 36v 10Ah battery is £202.

Sure, we'd all prefer a £2000+ Cube or something better if we had the choice and budget, but we're not all that lucky. Maybe upgrade the brakes to hydraulic for £40, but the existing mechanical discs would do the job fine at least to start with.

There's a Van-dweller on Youtube running an Eleglide bike long term, and he loves it.

View attachment 54373
Yes, there's quite a lot of youtube reviews (where the reviewer has been given the bike) . Also found this review quite helpful https://en.gizchina.it/2022/12/recensione-eleglide-citycrosser-bici-elettrica-economica/ with some pros and cons

The one area that would be a concern is customer service, but maybe buy from a bike shop that has a good reputation for customer service that does price match - maybe https://theelectricrevolution.co.uk/products/eleglide-citycrosser
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: cyclebuddy

saneagle

Esteemed Pedelecer
Oct 10, 2010
7,005
3,241
Telford
I like @Peter.Bridge 's suggestion of the Eleglide Citycrosser at £599. It's got all the extra bits @Woosh mentioned in post #20 for a commute (mudguards, stand, front light, 700c puncture-proof tyres, even a front rack), rapid-fire 7-speed Shimano gears (presumably Tourney, but nothing wrong with that), and a 10Ah battery that should manage a 20 mile commute... and it claims a proper torque sensor too. I think it looks pretty respectable, and that's an amazing discount/bargain. Not sure if that's a Dorado battery, but I saw replacement 36v/10Ah ones for £220ish somewhere. EDIT: Looking further into this, Eleglide have a UK/EU warehouse and offer a quite good range of essential spares for this bike here. A spare 36v 10Ah battery is £202.

Sure, we'd all prefer a £2000+ Cube or something better if we had the choice and budget, but we're not all that lucky. Maybe upgrade the brakes to hydraulic for £40, but the existing mechanical discs would do the job fine at least to start with.

There's a Van-dweller on Youtube running an Eleglide bike long term, and he loves it.

View attachment 54373
Torque sensor might sound like a good idea, but it makes any repairs a lot more complicated and expensive. Also, cheap Chinese torque sensors don't give a ride like a Bosch. Some are just used as a switch like a normal pedal sensor. Also, the battery is not as ubiquitous as the hailong type, and it has smaller capacity and is more expensive to replace. That bike looks great and will be good while it's working.

Mudguards and a rack cost around £20 together, and they can be easily fitted to any bike, so shouldn't be a deciding factor for a bike unless there are two very similar bikes at the same price, and one has them and the other doesn't.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: robert44 and sjpt

sjpt

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jun 8, 2018
3,850
2,763
Winchester
I agree with the comments on torque sensor and battery. The advert claims an absurd 75km range (without even using the 'up to' getout (***)), but it should be good for 20 miles. As above, you will be limited for choice of replacement when the time comes.

Mudguards aren't always that easy to fit if clearance is tight so it is helpful to have them prefitted. The choice of a front rack seems a bit odd for that bike.

Not as important on an ebike as a regular one, but I'd still want a wider range of gears.

I find a kickstand near the back (like that bike) gives better stability than one at the bottom bracket.

Having a regular non-suspension seatpost is a plus at that price range.

You'll probably need very regular checking on the spokes if you are riding that regularly, the wheels will almost certainly to be a weak point.

(***) edit, I see that further down the page a second reference to 75km is much clearer about the 'up to'.
 

cyclebuddy

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 2, 2016
1,640
771
Beds & Norfolk
Torque sensor might sound like a good idea, but it makes any repairs a lot more complicated and expensive. Also, cheap Chinese torque sensors don't give a ride like a Bosch. Some are just used as a switch like a normal pedal sensor. Also, the battery is not as ubiquitous as the hailong type, and it has smaller capacity and is more expensive to replace. That bike looks great and will be good while it's working.

Mudguards and a rack cost around £20 together, and they can be easily fitted to any bike, so shouldn't be a deciding factor for a bike unless there are two very similar bikes at the same price, and one has them and the other doesn't.
When the OP's total budget is £600, all those extra bits soon add up. The important thing IMHO is that the oft-difficult-bits-to-replace like battery, display, charger, torque sensor etc are available to buy direct from the makers website for very reasonable money (curiously the controller isn't listed, but given everything else is I'm sure it would be if you asked). Yes, your replacement battery options are more limited as the battery is integrated, but many here pay through the nose for "on-trend" features like that... remembering of course that this whole bike is cheaper than just a Bosch battery.

Amazon reviews for this model are almost exclusively favorable - the small minority giving "critical" ratings not even leaving a comment as to why.

It seems such a great package at that price, I'm almost inclined to buy one just for a laugh... but I'm already at n+2 e-bikes.
 

Woosh

Trade Member
May 19, 2012
20,451
16,916
Southend on Sea
wooshbikes.co.uk
Torque sensor might sound like a good idea, but it makes any repairs a lot more complicated and expensive.
We'll getting a new bottom bracket torque sensor (BBTS) system next week that I hope will fix that issue and give us a USP for building cheap bikes next year. The whole system minus the battery and motor wheel sells for £100 to speed up adoption. Simple plug and play waterproof wiring makes for easy installation. The most difficult job is to whip out the old BB.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Az.

thelarkbox

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 23, 2023
1,252
385
oxon
Decathlon batteries are reasonable at £279 for my 500E bike, but I might be looking to recell after the 2 year warranty period. Hopefully long after 2 years:)
How often do you charge? are you close to getting the 'expected' 500 charge cycles?? (does anyone get 500 or a 1000 charge cycles?? or is that just what they all say??)

Granted a well placed "most" should have sat in my post, Not all 'intergral' batteries are a bad deal it seems, would you grant me a many, or a most even?
 

Peter.Bridge

Esteemed Pedelecer
Apr 19, 2023
1,328
609
We'll getting a new bottom bracket torque sensor (BBTS) system next week that I hope will fix that issue and give us a USP for building cheap bikes next year. The whole system minus the battery and motor wheel sells for £100 to speed up adoption. Simple plug and play waterproof wiring makes for easy installation. The most difficult job is to whip out the old BB.
That sounds really interesting - will you be selling that so we could install on exisiting kit builds ?
 

Az.

Esteemed Pedelecer
Apr 27, 2022
2,092
932
Plymouth
Amazon Prime days soon. There is a chance they will have some ebikes on 50% offer again.
 

Woosh

Trade Member
May 19, 2012
20,451
16,916
Southend on Sea
wooshbikes.co.uk
That sounds really interesting - will you be selling that so we could install on exisiting kit builds ?
Yes, hopefully in two to three weeks.
 

peterjd

Pedelecer
Sep 18, 2019
213
52
How often do you charge? are you close to getting the 'expected' 500 charge cycles?? (does anyone get 500 or a 1000 charge cycles?? or is that just what they all say??)

Granted a well placed "most" should have sat in my post, Not all 'intergral' batteries are a bad deal it seems, would you grant me a many, or a most even?
Usually after it is below 50% on the display. Haven't really checked the range but does seem only a little less than the 90Km they claim at modest assistance (ie 1 and 2 settings). Because of the torque sensor I think I do put a little more effort into cycling than I would with a cadence sensor but that's what I wanted.
PS It is in fact the 11.6Ah battery which is quoted at £299.99
 
Last edited: