Leigh
Further to a previous post where you said the police have no right to take your bike, I fell you are a bit misguided on that point as you correctly said that unless the police have proof and not suspicions, or you’re not committing or about to commit an offence an offence they have no right under the law. Now that point is a problem, as dealing with the police for the last 40yrs I have found in my experience that the low level constables and their knowledge of the intricacies of the law is somewhat questionable.
So what would happen if they acted ‘above the colour of law’? Firstly they would take your bike, if you protested they act in a manner to agitate and escalate the situation (even though their training manuals instruct to de-escalate) for a stupid or aggressive reaction from yourself which then puts them into arrest mode. You would be charged with various offences because of their suspicions and your reaction to the stop.
Your redress would be very futile and complicated as they hold the trump cards being well organised with an inherent belief to protect their own.
Now the police bash above is over what would happen if illegal bike were ridden without checks to an extent where in the end legislative measure will be put in place for all us ebikers to register our bikes, insure our bikes, maintain our bikes (MOT) etc etc. This comes at a cost to us.
I for one dislike having police go above the law but I feel it’s a catch 22 situation they are damned if they stop us and damned if they don’t.
It’s a good poll if you tweeted the original remit, as it’s been a well participated post.
LeighIf you didn't feed yourself then you wouldn't be alive, and I don't care how suspicious you are. You're not riding my bike.
Further to a previous post where you said the police have no right to take your bike, I fell you are a bit misguided on that point as you correctly said that unless the police have proof and not suspicions, or you’re not committing or about to commit an offence an offence they have no right under the law. Now that point is a problem, as dealing with the police for the last 40yrs I have found in my experience that the low level constables and their knowledge of the intricacies of the law is somewhat questionable.
So what would happen if they acted ‘above the colour of law’? Firstly they would take your bike, if you protested they act in a manner to agitate and escalate the situation (even though their training manuals instruct to de-escalate) for a stupid or aggressive reaction from yourself which then puts them into arrest mode. You would be charged with various offences because of their suspicions and your reaction to the stop.
Your redress would be very futile and complicated as they hold the trump cards being well organised with an inherent belief to protect their own.
Now the police bash above is over what would happen if illegal bike were ridden without checks to an extent where in the end legislative measure will be put in place for all us ebikers to register our bikes, insure our bikes, maintain our bikes (MOT) etc etc. This comes at a cost to us.
I for one dislike having police go above the law but I feel it’s a catch 22 situation they are damned if they stop us and damned if they don’t.
It’s a good poll if you tweeted the original remit, as it’s been a well participated post.