i had big apples before the marathon plus' - they felt marginally more free rolling, and as if they provided somewhat betetr cushioning (th erubber is thinner, more elastic i think) - but thorns aside, if you are in an area with lots of broken glass, they can puncture. Mine did - after about 1000 miles to befair, but i replaced with marathon plus' because i was using the bike to get to work and being late was unaceptable, so the small sacrifice in ride and rolling resistance felt worth paying....but hopeless on the road.
Another vote for Schwalbe Big Apple (and Fat Frank, similar, only available in 2.35)
I can't remember ever having a puncture with these in about 4000 country miles, where thorns can otherwise be an issue.