I have a pair, and they certainly do the job! However, the fabric is quite stiff and heavy should you wish to pedal much, and there is no access to pockets - the wearer is expected to have a full set of webbing, pouches, etc., to carry small kit. I also have a Gore-tex smock, the best waterproof jacket ever, but as it is in camo colours I am very wary of using it in poor light conditions on my bike, preferring bright fluoro nylon.