Gardener choosing a bike for pulling a trailer around a city

lawbow

Finding my (electric) wheels
Feb 2, 2024
11
1
Hi everyone, I've been browsing this forum in recent days and it seems like there are a lot of friendly people with helpful information and experience to share so I thought perhaps people would have some useful perspectives on what sort of bike would suit my needs.

Background is I'm a gardener working in London and I do nearly all of my work by bike and when I very occasionally need a van I rent one for the day. I've occasionally considered getting a van but doing everything by bike is better for the planet, in London usually quicker, cheaper running costs, and also avoid endless issues with parking and LNTs.

I bring all my tools with me on a Burley Travoy trailer:
Image 1.jpg

very manoeuvrable and can take a decent load and copes well with longer tools. I'm currently dragging it around with my 1970s Carlton Gran Tour which is in desperate need of some TLC. I had been thinking about spending a load of money on new wheels, deraileur, brakes, etc. and then had started to wonder about converting it (looking at a swytch kit).

Then I thought perhaps I'd be better off just getting an Ebike and the slowly doing up the Carlton as a relaxed project, on the cheap by buying used parts and keeping it unnelectrified (or perhaps converting it with a kit from Woosh after the rest of the bike is sorted out). As I use my bike for work almost every day it would be useful to have two for when something goes wrong with one

I started off looking at cross frame electric bikes, somewhat in a similar vein to my old Carlton tourer but slowly I've been drawn to the idea of a folder. It would be possible for me to store an extra folder in my flat (even though I understand they don't fold down that small) and when I'm working I wouldn't need to lock it to a lamp post outside my clients' houses as I doubt it is bulkier or heavier than a fully loaded trailer which I regularly carry through clients houses to their back garden. It also strikes me that although a folder doesn't look ideal for pulling a load at first glance, it seems to me that the smaller wheel size would in fact be better at accelerating when the traffic lights turn green and pulling a load up hills (my two main motivations for wanting to electrify). It would also have the added advantage of having a pannier rack low enough to have panniers that don't interfere with the trailer which would be very useful.

I'm not interested in going especially fast, I'm 5'10 and a little over 12 stone, a full trailer load (including trailer) would be about 32kg but most often more like 20kg or so, plus perhaps a few kg in the pannier. I would ideally want something with a pretty decent range (comfortably doing above 20 miles with a load and some hills), and torque sensor.

I was looking at a Wisper 806 with a larger battery and torque sensor but then I saw that Tern makes bikes that seem more specifically designed for moving cargo on a small electric bike.

Are there any other good options I've overlooked? Does a folder (or at least something with 20" wheels) make sense for my use case? Also, does anybody body have any advice about buying second hand. I've seen some whispers in what seem to be near mint condition on eBay for considerably less than they cost new. Presumably it might not be possible to transfer the warranty but if you're saving ~£800 it seems like that may well cover anything that might go wrong? And if nothing goes wrong you're laughing.

Anyway, this post is already turning into an essay so I'll just finish by saying I'd be very interested in anybodies take on what sort of bike I should go for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Az.

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,310
3,214
The guy I buy Dahon spare parts from (one of the only shops in the UK that does), told me he regularly has frame issues with the Tern bikes he sells, but this happens a lot less with Dahons... and almost none when Dahons have the "Rebar" ie the reinforcement bar over the mid-frame hinge. My Bafang 250W BBS01B conversion is the 2006 Helios P8 (has a rebar), but it's an aluminium frame, so despite it being a Dahon, it's age will someday necessitate a conversion transfer to... a newer Dahon. Or a brand new frame of the same type - weirdly those do crop up, I could buy a new old stock Dahon frame today.


Photo of Snapped Tern Cargo Node here
















 
Last edited:

lawbow

Finding my (electric) wheels
Feb 2, 2024
11
1
Yeah partly for reasons of durability I'm now looking at possibly going for a 20" non-folder like an Orbea Katu-e
or a Raleigh Modum - from the reviews sounds like they'll also be a much nicer ride, possibly avoiding some of the problems with folder handling mentioned earlier. Seems easier to find a Raleigh in London to give a spin but the Orbea is a lot cheaper.

Does anyone have any views on how much difference a compact like one of these makes vs. a normal sized road bike? The Raleigh has handlebars that twist 90 degrees so that would make a big difference.
 

lawbow

Finding my (electric) wheels
Feb 2, 2024
11
1
Also looking at the cube compact hybrid. Is it generally a big advantage to have bought the bike from somewhere relatively close to you for servicing etc.? And are those Bosch batteries all standard so you can just get a new one if the original one gives ups on you?
 

jimriley

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jun 17, 2020
591
394
I have an Ikea trailer similar in size to that Homcom but personally I find it much less practical for my needs.
I'm also the proud owner of an ikea trailer. I pull it with my converted hybrid bbs01b, 42t front cog for the hills round here. I recently put a kit on my old brompton, tried the trailer with that, works a treat, certainly on the flat, not as much poke on the hills as the hybrid. I'd say stick a bbs01b kit on your bike, power and settings with can be tweaked easily with phone app and data cable.

it's the one shared earlier https://www.pedelecs.co.uk/forum/threads/brompton-with-trailer.46603/
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: lawbow

matthewslack

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 26, 2021
1,852
1,338
Also looking at the cube compact hybrid. Is it generally a big advantage to have bought the bike from somewhere relatively close to you for servicing etc.? And are those Bosch batteries all standard so you can just get a new one if the original one gives ups on you?
Interesting selection. A couple of people I know have small wheel cargo bikes, mainly used for their child carrying abilities. Not what you asked about, but I have learnt two things about small wheeled bikes from them, which might be helpful.

First, they ride great, no stability issues. Second, they use really wide rims, and tyres to match, which seems to be a big factor in that. They also use good spec Bosch electrics.

Looking at the bikes you highlighted, my favourite visually is the Raleigh, and it looks to have the chunky wheels/tyres. The Cube looks a bit upright and too short between saddle and bars. The Orbea rear wheel looks further back than necessary, although the extra wheelbase might be a good thing.

The Orbea is bottom end Bosch Active, the others are Performance. Better for towing.

The cargo bikes I mentioned are Tern (sorry @guerney) GSX, very expensive but absolutely loved by owner and kids, and Momentum PakYak, somewhat cheaper, larger 24" wheels, currently available 25% off in places.

Edit:

Raleigh has hub gears (good) but only 5 speed (not so good).
 
Last edited:

lawbow

Finding my (electric) wheels
Feb 2, 2024
11
1
I'm also the proud owner of an ikea trailer. I pull it with my converted hybrid bbs01b, 42t front cog for the hills round here. I recently put a kit on my old brompton, tried the trailer with that, works a treat, certainly on the flat, not as much poke on the hills as the hybrid. I'd say stick a bbs01b kit on your bike, power and settings with can be tweaked easily with phone app and data cable.

it's the one shared earlier https://www.pedelecs.co.uk/forum/threads/brompton-with-trailer.46603/
I thought that trailer looked familiar
 

lawbow

Finding my (electric) wheels
Feb 2, 2024
11
1
Interesting selection. A couple of people I know have small wheel cargo bikes, mainly used for their child carrying abilities. Not what you asked about, but I have learnt two things about small wheeled bikes from them, which might be helpful.

First, they ride great, no stability issues. Second, they use really wide rims, and tyres to match, which seems to be a big factor in that. They also use good spec Bosch electrics.

Looking at the bikes you highlighted, my favourite visually is the Raleigh, and it looks to have the chunky wheels/tyres. The Cube looks a bit upright and too short between saddle and bars. The Orbea rear wheel looks further back than necessary, although the extra wheelbase might be a good thing.

The Orbea is bottom end Bosch Active, the others are Performance. Better for towing.

The cargo bikes I mentioned are Tern (sorry @guerney) GSX, very expensive but absolutely loved by owner and kids, and Momentum PakYak, somewhat cheaper, larger 24" wheels, currently available 25% off in places.

Edit:

Raleigh has hub gears (good) but only 5 speed (not so good).
Thanks for the run down. Yeah this is basically my thinking - the most expensive is the best, the cheapest has the most drawbacks. Rather as you would expect. I'm quite happy with a fairly upright seating position as I'm not looking for high top speeds I just want help setting off from lights and going up inclines with a load of cargo. Was tempted by the Orbea for price reasons but the closest place stocking it is in Brighton and I'm in London so that's put me off rather.

Have also had my eye on some Tern options. The quick haul looks good but I'm thinking the long rear might interfere with my trailer as it attaches to the seat post. One reason I'm looking at 20" wheels is that will allow me to have panniers and a trailer (on my full sized bike panniers interfere with the operation of the trailer). Also looking at the Tern Vektron but based on advice earlier in this thread I'm thinking the handling will be worse and there's more to go wrong with the bike.

I have a test ride booked for Saturday with a place that stocks most of these models (and full size bikes I might even take for a spin for comparison) so I think that might help settle things.
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,310
3,214
on my full sized bike panniers interfere with the operation of the trailer
Full sized pannier bags interfere with pedalling on my 20" wheeled bike, so watch out for that - I eventually found bags which taper enough so my heels don't end up hitting them when pedalling. Then got two trailers, stopped using pannier bags. Of course, this might not be an issue on 20" wheeled bikes with longer wheelbases, or if you have particularly tiny pedal sized feet.
 
Last edited:

matthewslack

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 26, 2021
1,852
1,338
I went the other way for shopping trips with my 700c wheels. In the early days before novelty wore off I used the Nomad trailer, which takes four big carrier bags with ease. But as time went on, I found two 20 litre panniers, a 45 litre mountaineering rucksack for lightweight but bulky items works better for me. Plus a couple of bungy straps in case I need to use the top if the rack as well.
 

AngeG

Finding my (electric) wheels
Feb 6, 2024
8
0
Thanks for the run down. Yeah this is basically my thinking - the most expensive is the best, the cheapest has the most drawbacks. Rather as you would expect. I'm quite happy with a fairly upright seating position as I'm not looking for high top speeds I just want help setting off from lights and going up inclines with a load of cargo. Was tempted by the Orbea for price reasons but the closest place stocking it is in Brighton and I'm in London so that's put me off rather.

Have also had my eye on some Tern options. The quick haul looks good but I'm thinking the long rear might interfere with my trailer as it attaches to the seat post. One reason I'm looking at 20" wheels is that will allow me to have panniers and a trailer (on my full sized bike panniers interfere with the operation of the trailer). Also looking at the Tern Vektron but based on advice earlier in this thread I'm thinking the handling will be worse and there's more to go wrong with the bike. Another review of the game is here
it's the one shared earlier https://www.pedelecs.co.uk/forum/threads/brompton-with-trailer.46603/

I have a test ride booked for Saturday with a place that stocks most of these models (and full size bikes I might even take for a spin for comparison) so I think that might help settle things.
It's good that you are not chasing maximum speed, as an upright landing will be more comfortable.