DJI Drive system

matthewslack

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 26, 2021
2,363
1,594
A torque sensor is nothing more than a throttle operated by your leg, and the main problem with that is it’s useless when your feet are on the ground.

First and foremost, a throttle is a safety feature - for safe launching and low speed manoeuvring when you have either one foot down, or both. I can see how a torque sensor is perfect for mountain bikers but for everyone else a throttle is either very desirable or essential. Manufacturers ignore that at their peril.
Fair enough. I have no objection to them, as yet don't need one myself. I still haven't got over the bionic legs sensation of the torque sensor! Makes me smile every time I ride it.
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,802
3,328
Surely it’s obvious what many influential walking/rambling/hiking groups will think of this new DJI trail-shredder.
This new bike ought to be called "BOUNDER! OIK! CAD! NO!!!!" or something. Perhaps they can ramble around it without being spattered too heavily with great clods of mud and fox shiz.


The DJI will be interesting to watch come to the market, because it seems to be just as powerful as BBSHD.

Are bike manufacturers really going to claim a 250W rating for it? I might be writing letters if that happens.
I'm wondering if such high power from such a small motor is made possible by DJI's mystery special sauce high discharge rate lightweight batteries, and if so, whether owners will be disappointed with lower power from their motor, if they manage somehow to hack heavier generic batteries to use with it in a year or three, after their first set of expensive batteries are properly shagged out.
 
Last edited:

flecc

Member
Oct 25, 2006
53,439
30,765
First and foremost, a throttle is a safety feature - for safe launching and low speed manoeuvring when you have either one foot down, or both. I can see how a torque sensor is perfect for mountain bikers but for everyone else a throttle is either very desirable or essential. Manufacturers ignore that at their peril.
A throttle cannot be essential, our "safety" bicycles have managed without one for some 140 years.

The fundamental of an assisted bicycle in law is that it must remain a bicycle to be free of motor vehicle law. And bicycle motion is only by pedalling.

That is the rationale behind the ban on throttles for EAPCs.

But if you want an imitation motorcycle at low speeds of choice, then "single vehicle approval" is available through a test station privately or via Wisper. After that the machine is classified as a motor vehicle, thus satisfying the letter of the law in Great Britain, while not the spirit of the law.
.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bikes4two

Hoppy33

Pedelecer
Nov 29, 2023
30
13
Guys, I’m aware of the law and its nuances.* Not sure why this thread has got side tracked when my only interest is to respond to the OP with support for another mid-motor brand provided it has a throttle option.

I’m also uncomfortable about the power and speed of the DJI as presented in the video link, if only because I think it might attract unwanted attention. I’m sure that can be toned down but if there is no throttle option (and nobody has confirmed whether there is or not) then personally I think that’s a big opportunity missed. For me, a throttle is essential.

I have two hub-motor e-bikes, both with throttles and plenty of power, and both perfectly legal. I’m very happy with them.

*Edit: thanks mainly to this forum, for which I’m grateful :cool:
 
Last edited:

portals

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jul 15, 2022
761
227
Probably not that many other companies that could come in as disruptors with a product like that, if current versions don't have throttle be assured other models will have. With the rep for customer services and global service centres they have and fact that you can buy spares and have a right to repair albeit at mid dollar costs, probably you cannot go wrong, their drone pedigree is unmatched, only now being eroded at lower end by likes of Potensic and the superb Atom 4K that rivals DJI mini 2/3/4 for way less bucks.
 

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,802
3,328
Mark II: Self balancing wth turbofans either side.

Marl III: VTOL

Mark IV: Once prime market saturation is achieved, en masse atonomous AI Skynet controlled shredding of human race by said turbofan blades when the Chinese government wants a little entertainment. GAME OVER.
 
Last edited:

portals

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jul 15, 2022
761
227
The Americans are in process of banning DJI drones whether (like TikTok) that will happen or not is anyone's guess, no doubt if these motors catch on they will find a reason to ban or tax the ** out of them too.
 

saneagle

Esteemed Pedelecer
Oct 10, 2010
7,855
3,620
Telford
I like the idea that he was doing range comparisons rather than a range test, but why did he carry on after the controller cut the power right down when the battery was low. He did another two climbs with very little assistance and ended up gasping for breath from his effort pedalling, then claimed that as part of the range of the bike just because the LCD was still switched on. What could have been good ended up nonsense.
 

Raboa

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 12, 2014
856
311
53
The DJI is an interesting motor, it is entering a very competitive market
I think the BBS02 has readily available spares,readily programmed and competitively priced in its favour
One of the advantages of throttles is that you can exit traffic lights at a good speed which helps the flow of traffic
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cyclist

lenny

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 3, 2023
3,805
1,125
I’ve never heard of Teewing Bikes, but this Chinese brand is already teasing a DJI Avinox-equipped full-suspension e-bike
"The other detail that could give Teewing an edge as a newcomer to the market is that the UK has just abolished tariffs on e-bikes from China, which could allow pricing to be set lower than competitors."
 
Last edited:

guerney

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 7, 2021
11,802
3,328
Why not chuck a DJI into a well designed folding cargo bike? It'd breeze up hills. I doubt the Chinese will be making DJI motored cargo bikes anytime soon.