Just thought I'd add my thoughts to this interesting thread.
I bought a Cyclotricity revolver back in March this year and I've used it almost daily for a 12 mile round commute. I'll concentrate on the kit, as the bike its attached to is, as I expected is fairly poor quality.
I didn't know whether I'd be into electric bikes and didn't want to spend too much so went for the revolver. I'd always had fairly high spec bikes in the past and so as soon as it arrived I replaced the forks and stem/handlebars for a more comfortable ride and de-stickered it. I cant really comment on the gear components as I always have the bike in top gear (seriously I have NEVER changed gear on the bike as the assistance is so good).
The kit it's self has been excellent. I tend to ride the bike for 2 days (24 miles) between each charge but there is always power left in the battery. The motor is smooth and quiet, although I rarely use the throttle as I rely on the PAS for my assistance. I've only had one problem with the kit, the black plastic locking mechanism snapped and I've had to epoxy it back together. The other point I feel I should raise is about the battery cradle. It is secured by the bottle mounts and doesn't feel particularly secure and rattles a lot. As others have done I've put a couple of cable ties around it also to make it more secure.
In summary I cant knock the kit for the price and it has been 100% reliable in all weathers. I've now got to the stage where I'm hooked on electric bikes and so am looking to either buy a new bike or add a kit to a bike of my choice. Trouble is there's so many options out there I keep coming back to my cyclotricity kit as it just works straight out of the box.
Cheers,
Rich