The shortlists produced by those we elect, Tony Blair in the case of all female shortlisting for example, so my argument remains true.That's not quite true. The candidates we vote for are sometimes selected from shortlists drawn up of entirely one gender or ethnic background. This is done in order to satisfy someone who doesn't matter, but the process has the unfortunate affect of producing Dianne Abbots.
Oddly enough Diane Abbott was first nominated and elected as an MP when they were supposedly elected on merit, before the all-female shortlist appeared.
.