charger:
yes, a charger for Nicd or NiMh will not work..
but charging itself is easier than with Nicd/Nimh cells (no delta-peak-measuring needed)
there are peple charging them with notebook-powersupplies, or
regulated power supplies which many people already have at home for hobby-purposes
chargetime: when you can manage to charge with 10C, the cells are fully charged in 5min..
a friend of mine charges a 4cell-pack from his 12V-car-battery with a homebuild charger (~20-25$ for the parts) he made himself..
chargecurrent: 26A
the batts are full after around 5min charging and get 40°C warm during charging which is ok..
a A123-technischan said to us, that with that chargecurrent he will not see 1000cycles.. (but maybe 300-500
)
thats said for charging
Some questions if I may: 10 years life is claimed, but what is currently the longest term use (in time, not cycles) at rates similar to ebikes e.g. 20A max and 36-48V?
well, the batts are not that long on the market that we can say that excactly..
fact is: its about 1year we have that cells now in our community and the oldest (1year old) work same as the new ones
A123 Systems says:
A123’s Nanophosphate™ technology delivers exceptional calendar and cycle life. At low rates our ANR26650M1 cells can deliver thousands and thousands of cycles at 100% Depth-of-Discharge, a feat unmatched by commercial lithium ion cells. Even when cycled at 10C discharge rates, our cells deliver in excess of 1,000 full depth-of-discharge cycles.
other manufactor say: 6years for NiMh, and 3-4years for Lipos
when you take this in account i think we can be sure that the cells life more than 6years
(something only Nicd realy manage good, but they are toxic and low capacity)
lets say it this way: all tests sofar we made (overcharging for several HUNDRET ! cycles, deepdischarging, charging the cells in hot condition wihtout cooling down, ...
all this things are things, which killed Lipos very fast (sometimes in only 1 cycle !!).. and the A123 do survive such abuse
Also, from your experience, how technically difficult and dangerous is it to try to make an A123/FePO4 cellpack and use it
i solder the packs with 80Watt solder-iron
when you use a big,heavy solder-spike soldering is done in ~2seconds and the cells do get only barley warm..
A123 systems say, you should not solder the cells, because the heat destroeys the electrolyt inside..
but fact is: they sell "developer-packs" with solder taps on the cells for higher price..
we buy our cells at ebay (Dewalt-packs), disassable them and build our own packs and safe up to 50% money
we have not noticed shorter cell-life doing this (but we also have to say, that only few of us have managed to make more than 400cycles during this one year with our cells so far)
and: Sanyo or Panasonic also say in there specification, that it is not allowed to solder there nimh and Nicd-cells ==> and we do it for 25years now without problems
for using it: i use it in my helis of mine..
for example:
30A average current,
100A peaks..
and thats with a 1p pack !! (so the current of the motor is not divided by the count of parallel cells ! the complete load goes to the single cells)
i charge them up to 10times a day with 8A current (my charger can not more)
-> that means:
empty the cells in 4-5min
charge them immediatly without cooling in 16-17min
that works very good... (i would not want to treat normal Lipos that way *lol*)
and lastly, how quickly could one charge a cellpack like this for ebike use e.g. around 36-48V 10-15Ah min, (1) for best lifetime (2) in case speed-charge is needed and how portable would the charger be (could it be carried on a bike?)?
best lifetime: A123-Racing says: 4C charge, 10C discharge: over 1000cycles
fast charge: up to 10C is possible -> that are 5min charigng time (after 5min the batts are about 90% full)
charger: depends on how strong the charger should be.. the problem is:
when you want to charge a 16Ah-pack fast, you would need very high charge-power..
but even when you only want normal chargetime (1hour charge) 16A chargecurrent would be needed !
so: the big problem is the transformator.. but the same transformator is needed for a nimh-charger as well..
so size and weight should not differ at all
procedure of charging (technically) is easier than on nicd/nimh as said
@JohniStockie:
yes, the M1 cells iam speaking about.. don´t have experiences with the others.. even don´t know if you can get thouse cells a s a private person
for your "i want most drivable distance"
if you want the most capacity for weight the A123 are not ideal..
there "normal" lipos are better..
for example Thunder Power 2000 Prolite..
7s15p -> that would be 3,7 * 7 = 25,9V nominal and 30Ah
at around 4,1kg (without case)
so nearly twice as much capacity at same weight
disadvantage: after ~3 years the cells die, inner restistance goes up
single-cell-protection is neccessary
if something goes wrong this cells can burn
discharged too deep or overcharged (overcharging normaly with right charger and balancer can not happen) will ruin the batts immediatly
and last: the price... a 7s15p would cost 1500Euro
i use this cells for heli were i need most power at lowest weight and long flying-time...
but for 90% of my applications i meanwhile like A123 more..
+ no risk of fire
+ easier handling, more robust, robust case
+ and they will not die after 3years like my thunderpower do currently
+ can drive the same heli with same power (but only halfe of flyingtime) for 1/4 price of the thunderpower-cells !
As has been said, some or all lithium batteries involve more complex setup & charging than NiMH, and recelling or making a cellpack is quite technical by the sounds of it, so what I said above holds.
thats in my eyes not realy true..
or let say: from technical stand-points..
charging a lipo-cell is much more easy than charging a nicd or Nimh (which needs a delta peak sofistic ship inside, or some reflex-charging method to avoid memory-effect or/and lazzy battery-effect)
charging a lipo for that is very easy, building a charger by yourself (if you are good in electroncs) easier than building a nicd/nimh charger
its important to hold Lipos at same level, so not some cells are overcharged (which would ruin this cells or even make them start burning)
(Example: Lipos are allowed to charged to 4,23Volt per cell
you have a 10s pack
so the charger would stop at 42,3Volt
now: one cell is higher in voltage because of inbalance..
9cells are at 4,15Volt/cell -> that are 9*4,15 = 37,35Volt
so the one last cell will have 4,95Volt
this would ruin this cell
to avoid that a balancer is needed (single-cell charging, or build in in the charger.. or a external balancer you use during charging which can be bought for 35euro)
the Fepo4 are not that critical on that purpose..
it would be enough to look every 100cyles if they are still in balance..
if not, you charge each section of paralleled cells sepeartly.. (so in reality maybe once a year in ebike-situation)
for buying the cells:
in europe i pay 15,5euro per cell..
i buy them in the US.. with shipping to europe i come to around 10US$ per cell
last an maybe important:
do i think, that this cells are for everybody in the moment..
fromt he qualities of the cells: YES of course..
but there are problems:
do you get a package a non electrical person can implement immediatly in there bikes.. -> no
i see this cells for people who are not buying a complete bike and are satisfied the way it works..
i see this cells for people who build there own bike or make a conversion, who can solder... if this people use this cells, they get a cell-pack which will outperforme any lipo or nimh-cell for ebikes you can buy in the moment
the A123 is used for several electric cars meanwhile.. also some people convert the toyota prius to use this cells..
the world fastes electric motorcycle, the Killabike -
here you can see what is possible with this very same cells:
KillaCycle - World’s Quickest Electric Motorcycle
the killa-bike... world fastes electric motor-cycles..
from a 73kg A123-systems-pack they get
260kW (= 260000Watt) of power, over 350hp
this said: you don´t need to parallel the cells in e ebike for power-reason..
even a 8s1p pack (= only around 570g light) would power Johns bike easily..
(800Watt continously, 1800Watt short)
you have to parallel the cells, because with only 2,3Ah for a single cell drivetime would be not that great..
with the 2C lipos many bikeshops cell paralleling (they are often paralleled inside you - as user - don´t see or know)
and making large packs is not only needed and done to get long drivedistances but also because otherwise the weak 2C lipos would be not able to deliver enough power (~for example 30A) for the motor
well.. so much written.. hope there is nobody upset about this..