Go Faster Dongles! Here's another to consider

stumpy150

Esteemed Pedelecer
Oct 9, 2015
319
143
Yorkshire
you are missing the point as the police will seize the fire blade for no tax insurance ect.

yes you are braking the law but the police will still see it as a push bike so none of the above matters.

if bosch cant prove a dongle has been used the police have got no chance of proving it ;)
they can seize it as evidence - section 19 PACE then take it to bits and examine it or pay an expert to do the same.....:(
 

Gubbins

Esteemed Pedelecer
they can seize it as evidence - section 19 PACE then take it to bits and examine it or pay an expert to do the same.....:(
Yes well suppose there's plenty of money and loads of officers with nothing better to do.... My son was knocked of his bike last week... no one thought to check if his bike was legal, in fact police weren't really interested as long as the car was legal and he wasn't hurt.
He has had a bit of a battle with the drivers insurance company who never once asked if he had a dongle...
 

stumpy150

Esteemed Pedelecer
Oct 9, 2015
319
143
Yorkshire
I think its only a matter of time until they start checking , especially when there is a serious injury involved, or if there is a suggestion that the bike is electric and going like the clappers..... I wouldn't risk it....

Money - that's what our council tax precept is used for - :)
 

WorldClassAccident

Pedelecer
Mar 10, 2016
27
13
Hi,

New here and don't want to tread on anyones toes but why are you paying for dongles?

There is a much easier free way to do it that doesn't affect your motors warranty and is easy to undo allowing you to ride legally to private land and then bypass the speed restriction for as long as you like then re-impoose the restriction for the ride home.

I will leave you to argue over legalities and voltages but this allows me to ride off road on private land with the land owners permission at 28mph (fastest I can spin my legs) with all the normal levels of assistance working fine.
 

WorldClassAccident

Pedelecer
Mar 10, 2016
27
13
The electric bike has a limiter that uses the bike computer to calculate the speed and restrict assistance accordingly.

This sensor
20160306_090827 by WCA!, on Flickr

is triggered when this magnet goes passed and the speed is calculated
20160306_090851 by WCA!, on Flickr

If you strapped another magnet(from a magnetic kitchen door catch in this case) to the pedal arm thus:
20160306_104511 by WCA!, on Flickr

You can legally cycle to the private land where you have the land owners permission and then reposition the sensor so it is behind the pedal arm
20160306_104502 by WCA!, on Flickr

Then, because your pedals don't turn as fast as your wheels the speed calculated would be slower than it really was and the motor would continue to offer assistance at higher real speeds.

In top gear with this set-up the indicated speed of 7.6mph might equate to a phone GPS calculated speed of 28mph which is quite rapid off road. Don't forget though, it is only an assist so you still end up knackered after pedaling like a loon to test it.

You have then simply remove the tape and reposition the sensor for the ride home with the magnet left in place for next time. All legal and won't affect your warrenty.

Once more I state - only for use on private land
 

Gubbins

Esteemed Pedelecer
Hi,

New here and don't want to tread on anyones toes but why are you paying for dongles?

There is a much easier free way to do it that doesn't affect your motors warranty and is easy to undo allowing you to ride legally to private land and then bypass the speed restriction for as long as you like then re-impoose the restriction for the ride home.

I will leave you to argue over legalities and voltages but this allows me to ride off road on private land with the land owners permission at 28mph (fastest I can spin my legs) with all the normal levels of assistance working fine.
Prey tell... how is this possible? My toes are pretty tough anyway
 

Artstu

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 2, 2009
2,420
925
Bosch soon came up with a way of stopping that mod on early Bosch motors. Later ones give an error code.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RobF

WorldClassAccident

Pedelecer
Mar 10, 2016
27
13
Bosch soon came up with a way of stopping that mod on early Bosch motors. Later ones give an error code

Works fine on the 2016 Bosch cx motor equipped bike I bought last week.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anotherkiwi

anotherkiwi

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 26, 2015
7,845
5,786
The European Union
Bosch soon came up with a way of stopping that mod on early Bosch motors. Later ones give an error code

Works fine on the 2016 Bosch cx motor equipped bike I bought last week.
:) I love inventive people! Hey guys we have another inventor! :)
 

WorldClassAccident

Pedelecer
Mar 10, 2016
27
13
Your pedals rotate slower than your wheels.

This tricks the computer into calculating the speed based on pedal rotations instead of wheel rotations so thinks you are going slower than you really are. Therefore it keeps the assistance going.
 

Gubbins

Esteemed Pedelecer
Your pedals rotate slower than your wheels.

This tricks the computer into calculating the speed based on pedal rotations instead of wheel rotations so thinks you are going slower than you really are. Therefore it keeps the assistance going.
Right... so that must mean moving the wheel magnet to the crank arm...... [emoji10]
 

WorldClassAccident

Pedelecer
Mar 10, 2016
27
13
Yes - or do what I did and nick the magnet out of the kitchen cupboard magnetic close thing. Tape that to the pedal arm. That way you just move the sensor from next to the wheel - legal on road use - or move it near the pedal - unrestricted private land fun.

Did the earlier photos appear for you and do they make more sense now?
 

soundwave

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 23, 2015
16,909
6,512
i get a error code when i tried it on mine? maybe some others could confirm it now works again and save 100 quid on dongles.;)
 
Last edited:

Gubbins

Esteemed Pedelecer
Yes that makes sense, thanks for breaking it down....
.. I pay road tax so must own some share of the road, and as a private individual and road part owner I could use this on my bit of road..... my bit being the bit I am using at the moment.. ..
Seriously though. I don't want a dongle but I rather like the idea of being able to .. well see what it's like.... give it a try..
 

WorldClassAccident

Pedelecer
Mar 10, 2016
27
13
i get a error code when i tried it on mine?

Make sure you tape the sensor the right way round. The same side should face the magnet so it needs to be flipped 180 degrees
 

soundwave

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 23, 2015
16,909
6,512
it must be the different software on the bike as mine will not work like that tho does seem to work on others and the Yamaha motor bikes.

just have to see if any others can get it to work on the new cx motor bikes.
 

WorldClassAccident

Pedelecer
Mar 10, 2016
27
13
Try a bigger magnet or reposition the sensor.

The sensor it triggered when the magnet passes. There is no electronic intelligence in that bit. It is just a switch that sends the signal back to the computer.

The error code you get is probably saying the computer is not getting anything back from the sensor. It it the same error you get if you just remove the magnet altogether?
 

soundwave

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 23, 2015
16,909
6,512
its not that as Bosch did a software fix to stop you doing it so not sure why it now works less they missed it out on the new update??

you can also change the wheel size in the screen but made no difference when i last tried it on the peddle and just got error code.

with it like that tho what is the top speed b4 it will cut out? there are now dongles to remove any speed limit.