Unchained bicycle test

Footie

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jun 16, 2007
549
10
Cornwall. PL27
Interesting experiments on opportunist thieves :eek:

How safe is your city? Put it to the bicycle test - Yahoo! News UK

Text reproduced below as these pages have a habit of disappearing after a time :)

How safe is your city? Put it to the bicycle test.

By Fiona Ortiz Reuters
Thursday, October 9 01:24 am

BUENOS AIRES (Reuters) - How long will an unchained bicycle last on a city street before someone steals it?

Using hidden cameras and cheap bicycles as bait, an Argentine publicist set out to gauge crime in different neighbourhoods of Buenos Aires. The longer it takes for the bike to be stolen the safer the area, is his hypothesis.

"It's not a statistic but in a way it shows that the places where the bicycle gets robbed really quickly perhaps the quality of life is poorer," said Mariano Pasik, 37.

Pasik speeds up the videos, sets them to music and puts them on a website (Sitio no disponible en este momento. Intente más tarde. ). He hopes other videographers will join his nonprofit "Bicycle Test" project and create a worldwide insecurity index.

It could become an informal crime gauge akin to the "Big Mac Index," which compares the cost of the same McDonald's sandwich in different countries to give an idea of buying power of people in different places, Pasik said.

Pasik, who runs his own publicity firm Liebre Amotinada Ideas (Mutinous Hare Ideas), said the project is part art, part reality show, part journalism and part fun.

But it is definitely not vigilantism. Pasik blurs the thieves' faces and was shocked at comments on his website where people have called for the death penalty for thieves.

"What you see on the videos is that they aren't professional thieves, they aren't people who went out to rob. They are people who ran into temptation and decided to commit a crime, they become thieves at the moment they take the bike," he said.

He said he is also trying to show that the media fascination with crime, in places like Buenos Aires where armed robberies are rampant, is part of the problem.

"The popular fantasy is that the bike will be stolen in seconds, and it isn't quite like that," Pasik said.

In the latest video posted, a bike lasted an hour without being stolen in the unsavoury Constitution neighbourhood. But on the upscale shopping street of Santa Fe, a bike lasted a few short minutes before it was stolen.

A neighbourhood "passes" the bicycle test when an hour passes or when the filmer gets tired or runs out of batteries.

Fans of the site have offered Pasik free bicycles and sent in their own tests from Uruguay and Spain.

On the videos, the thieves often seem more like opportunists than hardened criminals.

"You see the person thinking and thinking and thinking, coming and going. Sometimes they talk by phone. They go away. They come back. It's more about an internal dilemma between good and bad, than about the bicycle itself," Pasik said.

Or maybe they are just in shock to see a bicycle alone without a heavy lock, an unusual sight in Buenos Aires, a dense metropolis of more than 13 million people.

So far in the Bicycle Test, no woman has stolen a bike.
.

Edit:
Opps! The in-text link does not work (anyone understand the lingo on the error page?) - Interesting idea all the same.
.
 
Last edited:

flecc

Member
Oct 25, 2006
53,152
30,567
The main message is roughly webpage not available at present, please try later.

Below is a request for the website owner to contact the admin department of their service provider hosting.
.
 

Danny-K

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 25, 2008
281
0
South West
By coincidence just finished reading that Yahoo news report before moving on to here, and two thoughts occur -

1) All the bike thieves are male; so far no females have been seen stealing bicycles.

Conclusion: Castrate all bike thieves - the change in hormones will feminise them and thus make stealing bicycles in the future an unthinkable act to them.

2) Something I've mostly believed, (despite news reports of the odd gang of professionals being caught and estimated to be responsible for 90% of thefts in their area), and that is, that the project above found that ALL the thieves were opportunists, ie., people unable to control temptation impulses and NOT out-and-out professional bicycle thieves.

Conclusion: Stop over-worrying about the 'best' lock and just put a highly visible deterrent lock on your bike - it's unlikely to be tested by all but professional thieves.

- If A professional has targeted your bike they just superglue your 'best' lock and watch you from a discrete distance set off home to get some help, leaving them ample time to use their bolt cutters on your locks.

P.S. The point about temptation reminds me of some interesting findings from the motorcycle world. Leave a motorcycle out overnight either visible from the main road or ON the main road overnight and it's likely to be stolen in short order. Throw a boring old tarpaulin over it and you can park it up for years on end without it going missing.
 
Last edited:

Footie

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jun 16, 2007
549
10
Cornwall. PL27
.... If A professional has targeted your bike they just superglue your 'best' lock and watch you from a discrete distance set off home to get some help, leaving them ample time to use their bolt cutters on your locks ....
Makes a total mockery of locking your bike. Thanks for the tip - not heard that one before.

My new insurance from ETA includes rescue and seems to include damage to my approved lock. So I should be able to call for help and stay with the bike - that will p*** the professional off no end :p :D
.
 

keithhazel

Esteemed Pedelecer
Oct 1, 2007
997
0
Makes a total mockery of locking your bike. Thanks for the tip - not heard that one before.

My new insurance from ETA includes rescue and seems to include damage to my approved lock. So I should be able to call for help and stay with the bike - that will p*** the professional off no end :p :D
.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

cant get this story, surely a "professional" would use his cutters on your chain quicker them messing about with superglue and then waiting around till you came back...surely they are too busy to hang around ror 8 hours...:rolleyes:
 

Danny-K

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 25, 2008
281
0
South West
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

cant get this story, surely a "professional" would use his cutters on your chain quicker them messing about with superglue and then waiting around till you came back...surely they are too busy to hang around ror 8 hours...:rolleyes:
Keith, the professionals are professionals precisely because they don't act on impulse alone. If you have a quality bike and end up having it stolen, it's odds on that you've been parking/locking up in the same public place on a regular basis. They'll monitor you to see if it's a regular habit of yours and then superglue the lock in the hope of sending you off home for help. They now have all the time in the world should they run into difficulties. If they took a chance at random they could find themselves deep into the cutting with the owner sauntering up behind them.

Can't find the link but it was the method one thief owned up to using when the police thought there was a major gang operating in the area when in fact it was one bloke only. Reported thefts fell by 90% after his arrest.

In the motorcycle world they go one better - often they'll see a very highly desirable and EXPENSIVE bike and not want to risk being filmed on street cameras stealing the bike - so again they monitor your comings and goings and are ready when you come to leave - following you all the way home - and breaking into your garage at leisure. The motorbike magazines re-iterate warnings on a regular basis to be aware if another biker appears to be following you; and if not sure to drive past your home until sure.

If you've got a crap bike Keith, then you're right, yours could get nicked by the local common numpty opportunist there and then.
 

Danny-K

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 25, 2008
281
0
South West
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

cant get this story
Keith - it's there! I've just clicked on Footie's link and there it is - it opened up on Yahoo's page of that particular story. Try again. Refresh or clear out cookies or whatever - it is there and clickable from Footie's initial posting.
 

keithhazel

Esteemed Pedelecer
Oct 1, 2007
997
0
Keith - it's there! I've just clicked on Footie's link and there it is - it opened up on Yahoo's page of that particular story. Try again. Refresh or clear out cookies or whatever - it is there and clickable from Footie's initial posting.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

sorry its my lack of expertese with english, when i said "i dont get this story" i meant i dont see the reason why someone would hang around for a week observing the comings and going's of someone just to steal a £k worth of bike,when they could watch someone lock a good bike, follow them a few hundred yards and see if they look like they have gone into work or similar then double back and "snip" with their cutters and be off....:)
 

Danny-K

Esteemed Pedelecer
Aug 25, 2008
281
0
South West
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

sorry its my lack of expertese with english, when i said "i dont get this story" i meant i dont see the reason why someone would hang around for a week observing the comings and going's of someone just to steal a £k worth of bike,when they could watch someone lock a good bike, follow them a few hundred yards and see if they look like they have gone into work or similar then double back and "snip" with their cutters and be off....:)
No, maybe it's my English that's at fault. No way do they spend 8 hours sitting with their chin in cupped hands watching you. They'll first notice a desirable bike and on the way back from whatever they're doing they take note that it's still in the same place in the same exact position. It's then they plan to take it - when it suits them, (hence the super-gluing and the owner out of the picture for a short while).

I'm quite sure when you say:

"follow them a few hundred yards and see if they look like they have gone into work or similar then double back and "snip" with their cutters and be off..."

that, that's more common than the outline I've told of above, gleaned from the motorbiking mags and news reports and consumer programmes.
 

Advertisers