SPD pedals- a beginner’s review

AlMel

Pedelecer
Jan 22, 2013
155
3
73
Essonne, France
It was on a 12 mile run that I inaugurated my Shimano A530 pedals, which are flat one side with the SPD mechanism on the other. It was my first time with clipless pedals, although my old Holdsworth has toe clips equipped with leather straps. Being used to leaning over quickly to release one when necessary, I was confident of mastering the new binding.

As recommended by the instructions, I first tested it with the bike immobile. Even with the SPD’s spring tension adjusted to its softest level, I noted that the sideways movement of the heel required to release the shoe has to be forceful and sharp.

Launching onto the cycle path I discovered that just placing the shoes on the pedals didn’t ensure the automatic engagement of the cleats into the mechanism. I had to find exactly the right position for them to connect. This may have been due to my choice of shoe: casual dual-purpose DZRs with relatively thick soles. However it only took a few miles to acquire the right reflex to click them in, usually on the first attempt.

With the required sharp movement, the heels are easily released. However, I noted a slight problem. On my Holdsworth, once the strap loosened, the foot of course stays on the pedal ready to hit the ground. With the SPDs, let’s assume you’ve unclipped the shoes anticipating an obstacle, as soon as you place them back on the pedals they immediately reengage! My current solutions are: a) if there are many obstacles ahead, keep to the pedals’ flat side; b) otherwise disengage at the last possible microsecond. Which can be interesting.

Continuing another few miles, I sensed I was absorbing the right reflexes. My shoes were disengaging and reengaging as required. In fact, why release them both? Only one needs to be freed when you know what you’re doing. So satisfied was I with my progress, that suddenly, for a reason that now escapes me, I decided to stop. I unclipped one foot to land gently on the other. It was during the passage from the vertical to the horizontal plane that the thought struck me that it would have been better to have released both.

I completed my journey slightly bruised but without further mishap.

Conclusion: although pulling up on the pedals called on muscles rarely used, they didn’t feel tired. The increased efficiency due to clipless pedals was pretty evident: I went faster with less effort. In particular, I didn’t notice the disappearance of the motor’s push past 25 km/h, at least on the flats. On the other hand, the use of SPD pedals requires a learning curve during which you must stay concentrated. Beware overconfidence!
 

103Alex1

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 29, 2012
2,228
67
Never looked back from using Shimano SPD clipless pedals. I found the ones which are normal on one side and clip-in on the other great for a month or so but then kept having problems hitting the clip-in side in traffic and found looking down to get the right side a distraction from riding.

I've now swapped pedals on both my bikes to PD-M647s which are amazing and perfect for eBikes. They're designed for DH bikes and have a great quality resin cage and you can clip in on both sides. I've also worn trainers with them on short rides with no problems. The platform makes it very easy to clip in and out, even in slippery conditions. I'd just make sure you use SH-56 multidirectional cleats rather than SH-51s - they're a lot easier to get out of in tricky situations.

After a short while it'll become instinctive - but till it does, yes, you do need to concentrate :)

PD-M647s are on sale for £39.95 (reduced from about £80) at Merlin Cycles at the moment. Plus money back from Quidco. Great deal. :cool:.

http://www.merlincycles.com/bike-shop/mtb-parts/transmission-gears/pedals-mtb/shimano-pedals/shimano-m647-spd-pedals.html
 

oigoi

Esteemed Pedelecer
Apr 14, 2011
467
7
Have also found it's a bad idea to pull a wheelie with spds clipped in if you go too high you go over backwards while frantically trying to pull your feet out of the pedals, and land on your tailbone in a painful fashion........
However they are amazing for jumping a bike and getting air
 

jackhandy

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 20, 2012
1,820
323
the Cornish Alps
The only time I recall pulling a wheelie, in recent years, was descending a slope that rapidly became somewhat cliff-like & one was a tad enthusiastic with the front brake - However, I have since discovered it's more conventional to wheelie on the back wheel when going up :confused:

As to Getting Air whilst jumping the bike, one frequently finds this problematical - often resulting in what can only be described as Wheezing :(
 

Fish-man

Finding my (electric) wheels
Sep 26, 2012
5
0
It soon becomes instinctive and as your pedals and cleats "wear into" each other the engagement / disengagement become much smoother and easier. just beware when /if you need to replace pedals or cleats ..... when you have got used to nicely worn in ones then a fresh pair seem horrendously awkward to disengage.

I find it so instinctive now that I often lift my feet off flat pedals trying to pull on the up stroke.

Top tip from when I was learning ...... with the pedal set at lowest spring tension you should still be able to wrench your foot out of the pedals regardless .... (or I always have been able to) meaning in an emergency you can still get out
 

Hugh

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 22, 2009
290
44
I've used these on various bikes for about 15 years now - always the ones with cage one side and spd the other. I like to be able to ride unclipped if ground is really tricky, and it's also good if you want to ride in normal shoes, e.g. on holiday to the beach, in sandals (I wish :rolleyes:), or just nipping out to the shops.

They seem to be very sturdy and trouble-free, unlike some more expensive pedals I've used in the past. Not very light, but that's all.
 

Zombie

Finding my (electric) wheels
Jan 13, 2013
8
1

Croxden

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 26, 2013
2,134
1,384
North Staffs
, that suddenly, for a reason that now escapes me, I decided to stop. I unclipped one foot to land gently on the other. It was during the passage from the vertical to the horizontal plane that the thought struck me that it would have been better to have released both.

That reminds me of the barrel of bricks sketch or the song Noel Murphy ' Murphy And The Bricks' 45 rpm - YouTube
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jazzist