Hello, I have a gearing problem. My partner ordered a kalkhoff agattu stepthru from 50cycles, she asked for a 19 tooth rear sprocket but they only had an 18 tooth, so she said yes to it. Since getting the bike she sais her bike is slower by ten minutes compared to her synergie mistral, and it is no good on hills or against wind, Any advise on suitable front/rear gearing giving good/reasonable speed and hill climbing ability. At the moment she hates the agattu because it is so much slower than the mistral which she was hoping it would come near to matching. The bike also has an underlying pulsing surge. on the Plus side it freewheels beautifully. Also when my partner phoned 50cycles about new battery conditioning she was told that the first charge conditioned it, and that was it, no discharging mentioned over the phone or in the manual. Do the batteries no longer need a conditioning charge?. Thanks
kalkhoff battery and gearing problems,
- Thread starter tiredlegs
- Start date
Agreed with Badpoet that you do have to do the two conditioning discharges but it won't help solve the underlying problem. Have you explained the importance of cadence? The lower the cadence the more power you get and provided you don't encounter too many hills the 18 tooth sprocket should help this. The other way of dealing with this is to go for an 11 tooth conversion as this allows you to raise the cadence by 20% or so. You would have to lower the gearing as the 18 and 11 combination is a bit too much. It should be possible to get similar journey times to the mistral and I say possibly even quicker if you know how to ride the Panasonics.
Last edited:
The pulsing surge that you refer to is the way this system works, it adds to the leg power on each pedal stroke so is very different from a hub motor system like the Mistral's
As Harry says, try to get used to the system and think of it as riding a normal bike but having magically stronger leg muscles. Keeping the pedal rotation speed lowish will give the most power as said. The other thing to note is that the motor input is in relation to the rider's input. If the rider input is low, the motor help will be low as well, regardless of what power mode is selected.
.
As Harry says, try to get used to the system and think of it as riding a normal bike but having magically stronger leg muscles. Keeping the pedal rotation speed lowish will give the most power as said. The other thing to note is that the motor input is in relation to the rider's input. If the rider input is low, the motor help will be low as well, regardless of what power mode is selected.
.
As Flecc says, she needs to get used to the system.
The hill climbing ability is possibly the best available but like changing from a petrol to a diesel engine, you need to know how to use it best.
If you have a gps or cycle computer on the bike, note that in top gear maximum power assistance comes at just under ten mph. Pedalling faster than this reduces the power. The surging you notice is more in the mind than in practice. Most people who've ridden my Tasman for the first time remark on how smooth the power delivery is.
As Flecc puts it, the hub motor is a moped - a powered vehicle with pedals. The Panasonic system is a bicycle with power assistance. It.'s not the same thing and means that a lot of the time the motor will be turned off and the Kalkhoff ridden as a normal bicycle.
Get her to persevere - some people are more adaptable than others - but in the end she'll really like it. Personally, I find no need to change the gearing, after toying with the idea, but even if I did, I wouldn't consider an 18t.
The hill climbing ability is possibly the best available but like changing from a petrol to a diesel engine, you need to know how to use it best.
If you have a gps or cycle computer on the bike, note that in top gear maximum power assistance comes at just under ten mph. Pedalling faster than this reduces the power. The surging you notice is more in the mind than in practice. Most people who've ridden my Tasman for the first time remark on how smooth the power delivery is.
As Flecc puts it, the hub motor is a moped - a powered vehicle with pedals. The Panasonic system is a bicycle with power assistance. It.'s not the same thing and means that a lot of the time the motor will be turned off and the Kalkhoff ridden as a normal bicycle.
Get her to persevere - some people are more adaptable than others - but in the end she'll really like it. Personally, I find no need to change the gearing, after toying with the idea, but even if I did, I wouldn't consider an 18t.
I have a 12T motor sprocket and 18T hub sprocket on a 7 speed hub. The 18T hub sprocket I have is equivalent to a 19T on the 8 speed hub.
The 12T/18T/7 spd combination means that I can do 25mph on the flat and still have power assistance. Most of the time though I cruise along between 18 and 20mph in 6th gear, or drop down to 16-18mph in 5th if there is a head wind or I am feeling lazy, tired or hot. My normal commute does not have steep hills, but on other journeys I have made I have found that I can get up hills of up to 12%, in 3rd or 4th gear with not much effort. I like to go fast, but having a 18T on a 8 speed hub would seem over the top to me.
Fitting a 11T or 12T motor sprocket transforms the bike, allowing power assistance to still be available at much more normal cadences and I would recommend this first before changing the hub sprocket. After this, if you are not really interested in pedalling at high speeds, then I would recommend that you work out what gear you are most comfortable in for top gear and use this to choose a suitable hub sprocket. A larger hub sprocket will make pedalling at high speeds more difficult, but will reduce the gaps between the gears.
The gear ratios of the 8 speed hub with various sprockets is as follows:
So at the moment, gear 8 is giving you 103.1 gear inches. If you are completely comfortable with gear 6 as your top gear (78.0 in the above table) then a 23T sprocket would make gear 8 similar to your current gear 6. Similarly if you would like gear 7 to be top gear (90.5) then a 21T would provide something similar (88.4) in gear 8.
The 12T/18T/7 spd combination means that I can do 25mph on the flat and still have power assistance. Most of the time though I cruise along between 18 and 20mph in 6th gear, or drop down to 16-18mph in 5th if there is a head wind or I am feeling lazy, tired or hot. My normal commute does not have steep hills, but on other journeys I have made I have found that I can get up hills of up to 12%, in 3rd or 4th gear with not much effort. I like to go fast, but having a 18T on a 8 speed hub would seem over the top to me.
Fitting a 11T or 12T motor sprocket transforms the bike, allowing power assistance to still be available at much more normal cadences and I would recommend this first before changing the hub sprocket. After this, if you are not really interested in pedalling at high speeds, then I would recommend that you work out what gear you are most comfortable in for top gear and use this to choose a suitable hub sprocket. A larger hub sprocket will make pedalling at high speeds more difficult, but will reduce the gaps between the gears.
The gear ratios of the 8 speed hub with various sprockets is as follows:
HTML:
18T 19T 20T 21T 22T 23T
1 0.527 33.6 31.8 30.2 28.8 27.5 26.3
2 0.644 41.1 38.9 37.0 35.2 33.6 32.1
3 0.748 47.7 45.2 42.9 40.9 39.0 37.3
4 0.851 54.3 51.4 48.8 46.5 44.4 42.5
5 1.000 63.8 60.4 57.4 54.7 52.2 49.9
6 1.223 78.0 73.9 70.2 66.9 63.8 61.0
7 1.419 90.5 85.7 81.5 77.6 74.0 70.8
8 1.617 103.1 97.7 92.8 88.4 84.4 80.7thanks for help & advise, aggatu gear battery probs.
thanks fellas,
would you believe it, my partner carole is happier with the bike today. She is now getting used to the differenent way power is delivered between the Mistral and Agattu. She used to ride the mistral flat out at times at a fairly high cadence, despite a hip problem. I have now ordered an eleven tooth motor sprocket, and will try it with original rear sprocket 21/22 tooth i think, and see if that suits her better.
I had a look on e-motion site, and yes, they do say condition the battery by running down twice, so i will follow that advice to maximise battery life. I noticed the same advice elsewhere, and on pedelec.
Pity there was not a higher ah battery available like a 14ah for greater range, though it might not fit the frame.
thanks fellas,
would you believe it, my partner carole is happier with the bike today. She is now getting used to the differenent way power is delivered between the Mistral and Agattu. She used to ride the mistral flat out at times at a fairly high cadence, despite a hip problem. I have now ordered an eleven tooth motor sprocket, and will try it with original rear sprocket 21/22 tooth i think, and see if that suits her better.
I had a look on e-motion site, and yes, they do say condition the battery by running down twice, so i will follow that advice to maximise battery life. I noticed the same advice elsewhere, and on pedelec.
Pity there was not a higher ah battery available like a 14ah for greater range, though it might not fit the frame.
There is a 15 Ah battery now, but it's much wider and needs revised cranks, cowlings and battery platform. Since it's then not interchangeable with the 10 Ah and the cost of the large one is very high, it's unlikely to be popular.
Since the 10Ah is only just over 2 kilos, I think the best solution for longer range is to carry a second one, and that method has more flexibility in how the batteries can be used.
.
Since the 10Ah is only just over 2 kilos, I think the best solution for longer range is to carry a second one, and that method has more flexibility in how the batteries can be used.
.
I would just like to point out the fact that, the Mistral is such an user friendly bike, that feels so natural to ride out of the box. It's a great introduction to ebiking, for a fraction of the cost of so called superior machines.
tangent: facinating reply. Two questions: 1) how is your range effected? 2) I'd never heard of a 12 tooth motor sprocket/ where did you get that?
Here's post from Jim giving the link for the 12 tooth sprocket, it's not a Panasonic part:
12 tooth sprocket for Panasonic unit
.
As Flecc says, check out the previous article. I would stick with the 11T as you have ordered it now. The difference between this and the more expensive and unofficial 12T is hardly noticeable. The 11T is much better than the 9 though.
As for range, I cannot really tell as I usually only do 15 miles per day. At the weekend I did 20 miles before recharging, including some fairly steep hills, but still had 3 LEDs showing on the battery.
this is a route with an 11t which i do and it starts flashing on the handlebars at half a mile from the end usually,i think its about 1 or 2 on the battery. if you look at the elevation its is not flat.... !
Gmaps Pedometer
Gmaps Pedometer
excellent mistral
Have to agree with you on that one, faster than my wisper 905se, but very much more agricultural. The bike has been ridden pretty much flat out everywhere. The battery has done two solid years and still going strong, maybe because it has been kept topped at all times topped up. thumbs up for the bike.
The Mistral my wife had is now 4 years old, a friend bought it off us, and I replaced the battery with a Ping LIFEPO4. With the Ping it now does 40 miles on a charge(30 miles previously), it's been super reliable too, literally nothing has gone wrong with it, except the battery wore out after 2 1/2 years, which is not bad really.
Thanks for a useful table - just changed from a 23T to 19T on my Pro Connect but kept 9T motor sprocket. Changing Mrs 'O' to a 22T/11T combination, she's less of a speed merchant! Can you explain what 'gear inches' are? Never quite understood the term but can see the effects?
Mike
Gear inches are used to compare gear ratios. A gear inch of 60 just means that it is like riding an old penny farthing with a 60 inch wheel. Penny farthings had no gears, instead they had the crank connected to the centre of a large wheel. The bigger the wheel the harder it was to pedal, but a greater speed could be obtained.
My table was knocked together quickly based on a wheel size of 28". However, I think this is probably inaccurate. I suspect that a 700c wheel and tyre is closer to 27". The table is just for comparing the effects of different hub sprockets. The numbers will be different for different wheel/tyre sizes. A non-standard chain wheel would also change the numbers. I will check my tyre size tomorrow and try to come up with a more accurate table, along with a table for a 7 speed hub.
The 700c wheel, fitted with 700 x 38 Marathon Plus tyres, is quite a popular combination amongst forum members.
An excellent start point with this setup when calibrating a mileometer is to use a circumference of 219 cms - it is the right setting for the Mavic A319 rim + 700 x 38 MP's.
This works back to a rolling diameter of 27.44 inches.
James
Ok, MP 27.44" wheels then, with a 41T chainwheel. I have added numbers for more extreme 16T an 17T sprockets. Here is the table for the 8 speed hub:
And here is the table for the unfortunates amongst us with the 7 speed hub:
HTML:
16T 17T 18T 19T 20T 21T 22T 23T
1 0.527 37.1 34.9 32.9 31.2 29.6 28.2 26.9 25.8
2 0.644 45.3 42.6 40.3 38.1 36.2 34.5 32.9 31.5
3 0.748 52.6 49.5 46.8 44.3 42.1 40.1 38.3 36.6
4 0.851 59.8 56.3 53.2 50.4 47.9 45.6 43.5 41.6
5 1.000 70.3 66.2 62.5 59.2 56.3 53.6 51.1 48.9
6 1.223 86.0 80.9 76.4 72.4 68.8 65.5 62.5 59.8
7 1.419 99.8 93.9 88.7 84.0 79.8 76.0 72.6 69.4
8 1.617 113.7 107.0 101.1 95.7 91.0 86.6 82.7 79.1
HTML:
16T 17T 18T 19T 20T 21T 22T 23T
1 0.632 44.4 41.8 39.5 37.4 35.6 33.9 32.3 30.9
2 0.741 52.1 49.0 46.3 43.9 41.7 39.7 37.9 36.2
3 0.843 59.3 55.8 52.7 49.9 47.4 45.2 43.1 41.2
4 0.989 69.5 65.5 61.8 58.6 55.6 53.0 50.6 48.4
5 1.145 80.5 75.8 71.6 67.8 64.4 61.3 58.6 56.0
6 1.335 93.9 88.3 83.4 79.0 75.1 71.5 68.3 65.3
7 1.545 108.6 102.2 96.6 91.5 86.9 82.8 79.0 75.6How's it going?
In terms of performance or general "feel", how have you found the sprocket combination of 19T rear with standard 9T motor? Or what's the "before" and "after" like? I'm considering my options...
Related Articles
-
MTF Enterprises announces acquisition of EMU Electric Bikes- Started by: Pedelecs
-
Wisper 806T folding bike wins Which? ‘Best Buy’- Started by: Pedelecs
-
Sustrans calls for protected cycle lanes- Started by: Pedelecs
-
Amazon launch their first UK e-cargo micromobility hub- Started by: Pedelecs
