Brexit, for once some facts.

Wicky

Esteemed Pedelecer
Feb 12, 2014
2,823
4,011
Colchester, Essex
www.jhepburn.co.uk
https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/fewer-than-6-tory-mps-turn-up-to-debate-petition-of-6-million/02/04/
Fewer than 6 Tory MPs turn up to debate petition of 6 million

It seems you need a million people before gaining the attention of one MP

Tory MP Julian Lewis pressed for the UK to leave without a deal and to go onto World Trade Organisation terms.

He said: “I, together with 158 of my colleagues – more than half of the Tory party – voted that we should leave on WTO terms and I think that should be the right solution.”

If that's the case TM really really needs JC onboard - can't see her conceding to his workers protections, 2nd referendum etc. She and her plan is being slowly crushed, trapped between the vice of hardened divisions.
 

oyster

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 7, 2017
10,422
14,609
West West Wales
It sounds like throwing in the towel but I suspect that TM is up to some trickery.
As the withdrawal agreement cannot be opened how can the CU and SM be legally attached. What stops the ERG kicking out these deals from the political declaration once the WA has been approved?
She says that she will make any indicative votes legally binding but what will be the motions in those votes?
KudosDave
I wouldn't put anything past the current government. So long as it seems to be in the interests of quite a number of their MPs.
 
Last edited:

oyster

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 7, 2017
10,422
14,609
West West Wales
Irony - apparently on 21st and 27th March, malicious obstructions were placed on a railway track. Threatening to bring the country to its knees because "Leave means leave". As if brexit isn't doing that anyway!

As I see it, blackmail and threats are what we absolutely do not want from anyone. To think that someone could do things like this and claim it is for the benefit of the UK!
 
Last edited:

50Hertz

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 2, 2019
2,199
2,403
Of course he'll meet her, but the problem might well be her intransigence, once again preventing her adding anything from anyone else to her deal.

JC will open by asking for Customs Union, and she will say no again. Where it goes from there is anyone's guess.
.
I think her idea of working together and a cross party agreement is to wear people down until they support her stupid deal. No other options will be up for consideration.
 

Woosh

Trade Member
May 19, 2012
20,379
16,876
Southend on Sea
wooshbikes.co.uk
It sounds like throwing in the towel but I suspect that TM is up to some trickery.
As the withdrawal agreement cannot be opened how can the CU and SM be legally attached. What stops the ERG kicking out these deals from the political declaration once the WA has been approved?
She says that she will make any indicative votes legally binding but what will be the motions in those votes?
KudosDave
it's the backstop. TM wanted it as insurance against the ERG.
It protects NI against her future replacement, at least in the short term until new GE.
 

Woosh

Trade Member
May 19, 2012
20,379
16,876
Southend on Sea
wooshbikes.co.uk
I think her idea of working together and a cross party agreement is to wear people down until they support her stupid deal. No other options will be up for consideration.
she can do a deal with JC but my guess, she won't. He will help her run down the clock then she'll adopt one of the solutions that parliament will agree through the indicative votes.
I guess when the clock runs out, she can always go Kyle Wilson way, 400 MPs will vote for her and confirmatory referendum.
 

oyster

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 7, 2017
10,422
14,609
West West Wales
He said: “I, together with 158 of my colleagues – more than half of the Tory party – voted that we should leave on WTO terms and I think that should be the right solution.”
So now the tory party consists solely of its MPs?

He can think it should be the right solution - his choice. But it isn't. He doesn't even say it is.
 

50Hertz

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 2, 2019
2,199
2,403
I’ve just seen that MP in the TV who was the intended murder victim of a piece of racist scum. She, and other MPs are calling for greater protection.

Would that be protection from the police who she and probably other MPs voted to cut back on? Cut backs to the police which have left them unable to protect the public properly.

As unacceptable as violence against MPs, or any person is, I don’t see why MPs should be a special case. They will just be required to take their chances, and if some loony blasts them straight in the bean, it’s TSB. They, the MPs, sanctioned the cuts.
 

50Hertz

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 2, 2019
2,199
2,403
she can do a deal with JC but my guess, she won't. He will help her run down the clock then she'll adopt one of the solutions that parliament will agree through the indicative votes.
I guess when the clock runs out, she can always go Kyle Wilson way, 400 MPs will vote for her and confirmatory referendum.
I’m liking the idea of another public vote. That could sort this mess out rather quickly without a need for negotiations and withdrawal agreements.
 

Danidl

Esteemed Pedelecer
Sep 29, 2016
8,611
12,256
73
Ireland
I’ve just seen that MP in the TV who was the intended murder victim of a piece of racist scum. She, and other MPs are calling for greater protection.

Would that be protection from the police who she and probably other MPs voted to cut back on? Cut backs to the police which have left them unable to protect the public properly.

As unacceptable as violence against MPs, or any person is, I don’t see why MPs should be a special case. They will just be required to take their chances, and if some loony blasts them straight in the bean, it’s TSB. They, the MPs, sanctioned the cuts.
Sorry 50 Hz, while I can understand your frustration , Public Representatives are a special case.
 

jonathan.agnew

Esteemed Pedelecer
Dec 27, 2018
2,400
3,381
Sorry 50 Hz, while I can understand your frustration , Public Representatives are a special case.
In part i agree - when an mp is physically attacked, representative democracy is being attacked, we need to protect that at any cost - but in part i don't, my OH had to travel through north london yesterday,while the four serial stabbings had happened, under the tories we live in an increasingly divided society in which ordinary lives dont matter
 

oyster

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 7, 2017
10,422
14,609
West West Wales
I’m liking the idea of another public vote. That could sort this mess out rather quickly without a need for negotiations and withdrawal agreements.
If it delivers a very clear result then, yes, it might be a major step towards sorting this out. My concern is if it doesn't do so. If it is a knife-edge result, it does nothing positive.

Then we have the issues like turnout, voter manipulation, eligibility for voting, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: robdon

50Hertz

Esteemed Pedelecer
Jan 2, 2019
2,199
2,403
If it delivers a very clear result then, yes, it might be a major step towards sorting this out. My concern is if it doesn't do so. If it is a knife-edge result, it does nothing positive.

Then we have the issues like turnout, voter manipulation, eligibility for voting, etc.

I could be wrong, but I sense that there is a shift towards remain amongst the public. I think remain could win in second vote by a greater margin than leave won by during the first vote.

It seems as though people now have a clearer understanding of the country’s ability to work and survive outside of the EU. We now have some actual evidence of this, as opposed to theories at the time of the last referendum.

That is just a guess, so don’t hold me to it.
 

Nev

Esteemed Pedelecer
May 1, 2018
1,507
2,520
North Wales
I could be wrong, but I sense that there is a shift towards remain amongst the public. I think remain could win in second vote by a greater margin than leave won by during the first vote.

It seems as though people now have a clearer understanding of the country’s ability to work and survive outside of the EU. We now have some actual evidence of this, as opposed to theories at the time of the last referendum.

That is just a guess, so don’t hold me to it.
I think your correct there seems to be a definite shift in public opinion over the last few weeks towards remain. I think people are now far better informed now then they were 3 years ago as to what leaving actually means. I know a couple of people that were very strong leavers and although they would not vote to remain in another referendum they both said they would not bother to vote.

I suspect there are an awful lot of people who would do exactly the same thing, and that a lot of remain voters that did not bother to vote last time because they thought remain would win, would make sure they voted next time.

The one thing we do need to remember though was that remain started off the campaign with a big lead and frittered it was with their hopeless effort, the same thing could happen again.
 

oldgroaner

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 15, 2015
23,461
32,613
80
If it delivers a very clear result then, yes, it might be a major step towards sorting this out. My concern is if it doesn't do so. If it is a knife-edge result, it does nothing positive.

Then we have the issues like turnout, voter manipulation, eligibility for voting, etc.
Now that is a risk worth taking, for how could we possibly be worse off if it's a draw?
parliament will have to work on it again that's all.
 
Last edited:

oyster

Esteemed Pedelecer
Nov 7, 2017
10,422
14,609
West West Wales
Now that is a risk worth taking, for how could we possibly be worse off if it's a draw?
parliament will have to work on it again that's all.
I tried to make that reply neutral. But I do agree that a near-draw would likely cause exasperation rather than a fundamental change.
 

Advertisers